St Augustine's Best Sports Bars [Updated 2025]

With a passion for great food and the electric atmosphere of game day, I dove headfirst into the vibrant sports bar scene of St. Augustine, and let me tell you, there are some real treasures out there! After reviewing 12 top locations, I’ve uncovered the spots that not only serve up the best brews and bites but also capture the spirit of camaraderie that makes watching a game so thrilling.

Trust me, I’ve spent countless hours soaking in the ambiance, chatting with locals, and sampling menus that make you want to cheer just as much for the food as for your team. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just looking for a fun night out, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to go for an unforgettable experience!

TailGators Sports Pub

Highlights
Friendly staff
Affordable drink prices
Patio seating
Video poker machines
Pool table available

Review of TailGators Sports Pub

When it comes to finding the perfect spot to catch the big game in St Augustine, TailGators Sports Pub easily claims the crown. The moment I walked through the doors, I was greeted by the friendly staff who made me feel right at home. It's that kind of welcoming vibe that keeps sports fans coming back for more!

One of the highlights of TailGators is their affordable drink prices. Whether you prefer a cold beer or a creative cocktail, your wallet will thank you. I couldn’t resist taking advantage of their patio seating, which provided a perfect view of the screens while enjoying the fresh air.

For those looking to entertain themselves during game breaks, the pool table was a fantastic addition that kept the energy buzzing. And if you're feeling lucky, don’t forget about the video poker machines—they add an extra layer of fun to the experience.

Overall, TailGators Sports Pub combines the best of a laid-back atmosphere with vibrant energy, making it a must-visit destination for sports lovers. With great drinks, ample seating, and a lively crowd, I'm already planning my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best bars in St Augustine.

Ann O'Malley's

Highlights
Quaint pub atmosphere
Friendly and helpful staff
Outstanding pastrami sandwich
Tasty Rueben sandwich
Cool owner and bartender

Ann O'Malley's is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of St Augustine, where the atmosphere is as warm and welcoming as the friendly staff. Stepping inside, I was immediately drawn to the quaint pub vibe, perfect for sports fans seeking camaraderie. The bar is adorned with memorabilia, giving it a charming touch that makes it feel like a home away from home.

The moment we sat down, the staff was quick to greet us with genuine smiles and keen recommendations. I couldn’t resist diving into their impressive menu, where I settled on the outstanding pastrami sandwich—a culinary delight that did not disappoint. This expertly crafted sandwich was a perfect pairing with a refreshing pint while I chatted with the cool owner and bartender, who added a personal touch to the experience.

If you're a fan of hearty bites, don't miss the delicious Rueben sandwich. It truly excels in flavor and comfort. Overall, Ann O'Malley's is more than just a place to watch the game; it's a welcoming community hub where everyone feels like a local. If you’re in St Augustine, take a timeout and make this your sports haven!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville.

Aces Sports Bar & Grill

Stepping into Aces Sports Bar & Grill felt like finding my new favorite oasis in St Augustine! With an energizing atmosphere, this spot offers an impressive array of big-screen TVs for all the sports fanatics. I was instantly drawn to their mouthwatering wings and a diverse selection of local brews. The staff was both attentive and friendly, making me feel right at home. Whether you're there for the game or just to enjoy a laid-back evening, Aces hits a home run every time. Truly, it's a delightful hub for sports lovers and good times! Don't miss it!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in Jacksonville.

Prohibition Kitchen

Tucked away on gritty Charlotte Street, Prohibition Kitchen is a hidden gem that effortlessly merges historic charm with edgy flair. As a fan of both sports and good eats, I was delighted to find multiple screens showcasing games, paired with an inviting atmosphere that exudes camaraderie. The menu boasts mouthwatering burgers and locally crafted brews, perfect for fueling cheering fans. The bartenders are a lively bunch, ensuring your glass is never empty and your spirits are high. If you’re seeking a spot that blends delicious food, good company, and exciting sports, Prohibition Kitchen might just be the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Jacksonville.

Auggie's Draft Room

Auggie's Draft Room is a gem for any sports fan! The atmosphere buzzes with excited chatter and the walls adorned with memorabilia create an inviting backdrop. Their extensive selection of local craft beers pairs perfectly with a menu that features mouthwatering bites, like their famed wings. Whether you're catching the big game on one of their many screens or challenging friends to a game of pool, this place has a vibe that's just right. Plus, the friendly staff adds to the overall warmth of the experience. If you're hunting for a spirited spot to watch your favorite teams, Auggie's is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best club in Jacksonville.

Shaughnessy's Sports Grill

Shaughnessy's Sports Grill is a true gem in St. Augustine, blending a vibrant, friendly atmosphere with an impressive array of screens to catch every thrilling moment of the game. This lively spot boasts an extensive menu, where I found the signature wings to be utterly irresistible. The staff is exceptionally attentive, making sure every pint is filled and every request is met with a smile. Whether you're a die-hard fan or just in for a cold beer and a big game, Shaughnessy's offers a winning combination that keeps you coming back for more. A definite must-visit for sports lovers!

You might also want to check out the best night clubs in Jacksonville.

Muggsy’s

Muggsy’s in St. Augustine is an absolute gem for sports enthusiasts and casual diners alike. With a vibrant atmosphere and countless TVs broadcasting all the action, it's a fantastic spot to cheer on your favorite team. The mouthwatering menu features staples like loaded nachos and juicy burgers, perfect for fueling up while you watch the game. Their extensive drink selection, including local brews, keeps the spirits high. The staff is both friendly and attentive, ensuring you're never without your game day essentials. For a lively sports bar experience, Muggsy’s undeniably hits the mark. Who's ready for game time? 🍻🎉

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in St Augustine.

Candlelight South Restaurant

Candlelight South Restaurant is a hidden gem in St. Augustine that captures the spirit of sports fandom with a delightful twist! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a warm ambiance and a plethora of screens showing all the game action. The wings? Pure bliss—crispy, flavorful, and perfect for sharing (or not!). The bar offers a diverse selection of local brews, enhancing the game-day vibe. Whether you’re cheering for the home team or enjoying a casual night out, this spot strikes a charming balance between a welcoming atmosphere and infectious enthusiasm. It’s definitely worth a visit for any sports lover!

You might also want to check out the best breweries in Jacksonville.

No Name Bar

Nestled by the water, No Name Bar effortlessly combines a laid-back vibe with the thrill of game day. The eclectic decor and friendly staff immediately made me feel at home. With multiple screens displaying all the action, it's a paradise for sports enthusiasts. For those with a craving, their menu offers mouthwatering bites that pair perfectly with a cold drink—try the fish tacos! The outdoor seating provides a beautiful view, making it ideal for both locals and visitors alike. If you're seeking a spot to cheer on your favorite team, No Name Bar is an undeniable gem in St Augustine!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville Beach.

Pierre's Pub

Pierre's Pub is a hidden gem that embodies the spirit of camaraderie and sports enthusiasm. As soon as I walked in, the vibrant atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug. The walls adorned with memorabilia instantly grabbed my attention. A diverse menu paired with a comprehensive drink selection guarantees everyone finds something to enjoy. Whether it’s the thrill of live game days or the simple pleasure of a friendly game of darts, this pub delivers in spades. The staff is attentive and cheerful, making it a delightful spot to cheer on your favorite teams. Definitely a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best brewery in St Augustine.

Ice Plant Bar

Ice Plant Bar is a gem nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, where craft cocktails meet a delightful sports atmosphere. With its vintage vibe and industrial charm, this spot offers plenty of screen space to catch the big game while enjoying their locally-sourced menu. I savored the mouthwatering sliders and sipped on a tantalizing ginger-infused cocktail—perfect for those spirited cheers! The staff was not only attentive but also incredibly knowledgeable about the drinks they serve. If you're in search of a unique blend of sports and sophistication, Ice Plant is a must-visit!

Trade Winds Lounge

The Trade Winds Lounge is a hidden gem that perfectly blends laid-back charm with a vibrant sports scene. As I stepped inside, the walls adorned with memorabilia ignited a sense of nostalgia. The friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles and swift service, enhancing the experience. With multiple screens broadcasting the latest games, it’s the ideal spot for any sports fan. I indulged in their signature wings, which didn't disappoint—crispy and generously sauced! The relaxed atmosphere, combined with a lively crowd, makes this bar a must-visit for anyone looking to savor good food and great sports in St Augustine.