St Augustine's Best Bars [Updated 2025]

Whether you’re craving a laid-back vibe or the thrill of a lively night out, St. Augustine is bursting with unique bars that offer a taste of the city’s rich history and vibrant culture. After countless evenings spent sipping craft cocktails and enjoying local brews, I’ve narrowed down my top 12 spots that truly capture the essence of this charming town.

As someone who has wandered these streets with a keen eye for hidden gems and a taste for quality, you can trust that my recommendations come from genuine experiences. Each bar has its own story to tell, and I can’t wait to share them with you—let’s raise a glass to adventure!

The Tini Martini Bar

Highlights
Festive holiday decorations
Extensive martini selection
Speakeasy ambiance
Live music entertainment
Friendly staff service

The Tini Martini Bar is a delightful escape that’s perfect for any evening out in St Augustine. As I stepped inside, I was immediately charmed by the festive holiday decorations that lend a cozy and magical atmosphere to the venue. The ambiance feels like a secret speakeasy, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed, yet exhilarating night.

The star of the show, of course, is their extensive martini selection, which is nothing short of impressive. With inventive flavors and classic favorites, I found myself savoring a delectable Chocolate Martini that was both indulgent and delightful. Each sip was a reminder of the care and creativity that goes into crafting these cocktails.

Adding to the experience was the live music entertainment that perfectly complemented the vibrant atmosphere. The talented musicians created a lovely backdrop that made it all feel special. Furthermore, the staff was not only friendly, but also incredibly knowledgeable, ready to guide me through the extensive menu with enthusiasm.

In short, The Tini Martini Bar is a fabulous gem in St Augustine where every element comes together for an unforgettable night. I can’t wait to return!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville.

Forgotten Tonic

Highlights
Friendly, skilled bartenders
Amazing food and drinks
Festive seasonal cocktails
Beautifully decorated space
Must-try spot in St. Augustine

During my recent exploration of St. Augustine's vibrant bar scene, I stumbled upon Forgotten Tonic, a gem tucked away that truly deserves your attention. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the welcoming smiles of the friendly and skilled bartenders who made me feel right at home. Their passion for mixology was evident as they created some of the most delightful seasonal cocktails I’ve ever tasted.

The ambiance is a beautiful blend of rustic and modern decor, creating a space that's just perfect for a laid-back evening. I couldn't resist indulging in their fantastic food offerings which complemented the drinks perfectly—each bite was a revelation.

If you’re in the St. Augustine area, Forgotten Tonic is a must-try spot. It’s not just about the drinks here; it’s about the entire experience. Whether you're winding down after a day of exploring or looking to kick off a night out, this place promises a delightful escape. Raise a glass and toast to good vibes—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in Jacksonville.

Stogies Jazz Club & Listening

Highlights
Incredible staff service
Craft beer selection
Nightly live music
Great cigar options
Unique, vibrant atmosphere

Stogies Jazz Club & Listening in St Augustine is a hidden gem that captures the essence of a cozy evening out. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly rolled cigars mingling with the sound of smooth jazz floating through the air. The atmosphere is both vibrant and relaxed, making it the ideal spot for a fun night.

The staff here is truly exceptional—friendly, knowledgeable, and eager to help you find the perfect drink or cigar. I was impressed by their diverse selection of craft beers, each thoughtfully curated to complement an evening of unwinding. And if you’re a fan of live music, you're in for a treat! With nightly performances by local jazz artists, the energy in the room is always palpable.

What stood out to me was the welcoming ambiance that invites you to linger. Whether you’re a seasoned cigar aficionado or simply looking for a unique place to unwind after a day of exploring, Stogies offers the perfect mix of entertainment and relaxation. Overall, this spot is a must-visit, where every night feels like a celebration of art and flavor!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Jacksonville.

Ice Plant Bar

Tucked away in a charming historic building, Ice Plant Bar truly captures the essence of St. Augustine's vibrant spirit. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a sleek industrial vibe that beautifully complements the expertly crafted cocktails. Their signature drinks showcase fresh ingredients, and I couldn’t resist trying the house-made tonic paired with a refreshing gin. The atmosphere buzzes with lively conversation and the gentle clinking of glasses, making it a perfect spot for socializing. With its inventive menu and friendly staff, Ice Plant Bar is undoubtedly a standout destination for anyone in search of an unforgettable night out!

You might also want to check out the best club in Jacksonville.

Trade Winds Lounge

Stepping into Trade Winds Lounge felt like a warm embrace from an old friend. This charming spot, adorned with nautical decor, truly captures the essence of the coastal vibe. Their cocktail menu is a delightful treasure trove; I indulged in a refreshing Rum Punch—a perfect mix of sweet and zesty. The ambiance was vibrant, filled with laughter and live music that added to the electrifying atmosphere. Service was prompt, and the staff was genuinely friendly. If you're looking for a place to unwind with great drinks and a welcoming crowd, Trade Winds Lounge should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best night clubs in Jacksonville.

Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen

At Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen, I was immediately captivated by the quirky decor and inviting atmosphere. The craft cocktails are a must-try, especially the signature drinks that showcase local flavors with a playful twist. Each sip was an adventure! The small plates menu is perfect for sharing, featuring unique takes on classic bites. The staff was knowledgeable and enthusiastic, enhancing the overall experience. If you’re looking for a bar that combines creativity with comfort, Odd Birds is a standout choice in St Augustine. Don’t miss out on this gem—it's a cocktail lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in St Augustine.

No Name Bar

Nestled along the picturesque bay, No Name Bar is a hidden gem that captures the very essence of St. Augustine's vibrant nightlife. The moment I stepped in, the laid-back atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug. With craft cocktails that flirt with creative flavors and local brews that tell the story of the region, I found myself lost in choice. The friendly bartenders made sure my glass was never empty, while the outdoor seating offered stunning views of the sunset. If you're seeking a magical blend of ambiance and community, No Name Bar should be top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville Beach.

Scarlett O'Hara's

Stepping into Scarlett O'Hara's feels like a charming escape into the South. This lively bar boasts a delightful combination of history and hospitality that immediately draws you in. With its vibrant atmosphere and dazzling cocktails, every sip is a brush with Southern flair. The southern-inspired menu pairs wonderfully with their extensive drink selection. I savored their signature Sweet Tea Vodka Lemonade, a perfect blend of refreshing and sweet. The friendly staff exudes warmth, making you want to linger just a little longer. If you're in St Augustine, don't miss this gem where every visit promises a touch of Southern sunshine!

You might also want to check out the best brewery in St Augustine.

Muggsy’s

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Muggsy’s is a delightful haven for those seeking a vibrant atmosphere and a fantastic selection of brews. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a lively crowd and an eclectic decor that sets the perfect backdrop for unwinding. Their craft cocktails are a must-try, particularly the signature Muggsy Mule, which delivers a refreshing zing. Friendly bartenders add a personal touch, making each visit feel special. Whether you're here to catch a game or engage in lighthearted banter, Muggsy’s effortlessly combines fun and warmth, making it a top contender in St. Augustine's bar scene.

Prohibition Kitchen

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Prohibition Kitchen is an absolute gem for cocktail enthusiasts and food lovers alike. The ambiance is a delightful nod to the Roaring Twenties, complete with vintage decor that whispers secrets of the past. I was particularly captivated by their craft cocktails, especially the Spicy Paloma, which perfectly blended tequila and zesty grapefruit. The menu also features mouthwatering dishes that are as creative as the drinks. Service was prompt and friendly, making this spot a must-visit for anyone seeking a lively atmosphere and exceptional libations. Cheers to unforgettable nights at Prohibition Kitchen!

The Drunken Horse St. Augustine

My visit to The Drunken Horse St. Augustine was a delightful romp through ambiance and flavor! Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, this bar exudes a quirky charm that's hard to resist. The cocktail menu is a clever twist on local favorites, with the Moscow Mule being a standout—refreshingly zesty and perfectly chilled. The rustic decor invites you to unwind, while the live music creates an inviting atmosphere perfect for sharing laughs with friends. If you're looking for a playful spot to sip and socialize, The Drunken Horse is certainly worth a visit!

The Tipsy Duck Parlor

The Tipsy Duck Parlor offers a whimsical escape that perfectly balances charm and creativity. Upon entering, I was captivated by the unique décor—think vintage vibes meets playful quirkiness. Their craft cocktails are a highlight; I savored the Ducktini, a delightful twist on a classic that left my taste buds dancing. The staff’s warmth and knowledge elevated the experience, making recommendations feel personal and fun. The lively atmosphere is perfect for unwinding with friends or starting a night out. If you're looking for a bar that's both inviting and exciting, The Tipsy Duck should definitely be on your list!