St Augustine's Best Singles Bars [Updated 2025]

You know how it feels when you walk into a place and immediately sense the energy buzzing around you? That’s what I’ve been chasing all over St. Augustine, and after diving into the nightlife scene, I’ve narrowed it down to twelve hotspots that truly stand out.

With years of experience and countless nights spent mingling with fellow singles, I’ve become a bit of a connoisseur when it comes to finding the perfect atmosphere to meet new people. Whether you’re looking for a laid-back vibe or a lively dance floor, I’ve got you covered with some insider tips that will make your next night out unforgettable!

The Well Bar

Highlights
Exclusive guest access
Craft cocktails perfection
Intimate and tranquil
Engaging bartender service
Charming outdoor seating

Tucked away from the hustle and bustle, The Well Bar is a hidden gem that needs to be on every single's radar! Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the cozy yet vibrant atmosphere—perfect for those looking to spark a connection. The ambiance is intimate and tranquil, making it ideal for relaxed conversations without the distractions of a typical bar scene.

One of the highlights of my visit was the craft cocktails perfection. Each sip was a delightful adventure, showcasing the bartender's creativity and expertise. Speaking of the bartenders, they were incredibly engaging, always ready to share a recommendation or mix a new concoction tailored to my tastes. Their passion for the craft truly elevates the experience.

I particularly loved the charming outdoor seating area, which allows for a refreshing breeze and the chance to mingle with fellow singles under the stars. It’s a place where the laughter flows as easily as the drinks. For anyone looking to meet new people in St Augustine, The Well Bar is a sophisticated choice that combines great drinks, ambiance, and potential connections. I can’t recommend it highly enough—sip, chat, and maybe even fall in love!

You might also want to check out the best bars in St Augustine.

The Tini Martini Bar

Highlights
Fabulous holiday decorations
Speakeasy ambiance
Extensive martini selection
Enjoyable live music
Friendly staff

The Tini Martini Bar is an absolute gem! Stepping into this place feels like entering a charming speakeasy, perfectly adorned with fabulous holiday decorations that set the mood just right. The cozy, intimate atmosphere instantly draws you in, making it an ideal spot for singles to mingle.

One of the highlights here is the extensive martini selection—they have everything from the classic to the imaginative. Whether you fancy a traditional dirty martini or something more adventurous like a passion fruit twist, your taste buds will not be disappointed.

The friendly staff at The Tini Martini Bar adds an extra layer of warmth to the experience. Their knowledge of the menu is impressive, and they’re always eager to help guide you through the choices, making you feel right at home. On evenings with live music, the bar transforms into an intimate oasis where you can sip on your favorite drink while enjoying talented local musicians.

For anyone seeking to connect with fellow singles in St Augustine, The Tini Martini Bar offers an atmosphere that’s both inviting and exhilarating. It’s a delightful blend that’s perfect for conversation and fun nights out. Cheers to new connections!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville.

Ann O'Malley's

Highlights
Friendly staff
Outstanding pastrami sandwich
Quaint pub atmosphere
Cool owner/bartender

Ann O'Malley's is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of St Augustine. As I stepped inside, I was instantly welcomed by the friendly staff, who immediately set the tone for an enjoyable evening. The quaint pub atmosphere made me feel right at home, perfect for mingling with fellow singles. The walls, adorned with charming decor, invite you to relax and strike up a conversation with someone new.

One of the standout features of this bar is the outstanding pastrami sandwich they serve – a must-try, even if you're more focused on meeting new people than indulging in food. The tempting aroma wafting from the kitchen serves as a great conversation starter. And speaking of conversation, the cool owner/bartender takes the time to engage with guests, making it easy to start chatting with others over a craft beer or a well-mixed cocktail.

If you’re in St Augustine and looking to meet someone special or just enjoy a great night out, I wholeheartedly recommend Ann O'Malley's. You'll find the perfect blend of friendly vibes, engaging conversations, and delicious bites to make your night unforgettable. Happy mingling!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in Jacksonville.

Bull & Crown Publick House

Highlights
Excellent food and service
Knowledgeable and attentive staff
Delicious fish and chips
Cozy indoor and outdoor dining
Great recommendations

Stepping into Bull & Crown Publick House feels like entering a cozy corner of England right in St. Augustine. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between casual and charming, making it an ideal spot for singles looking to mingle. With both indoor and outdoor seating, you can choose to bask in the sun or snuggle up in a warm nook.

The food is nothing short of a revelation, particularly their fish and chips, which is crispy and flavorful—perfect fuel for striking up a conversation with that intriguing stranger across the table. The service here is top-notch; the staff are not only knowledgeable about the menu but also genuinely attentive, setting the stage for a welcoming environment.

What stands out is how the restaurant invites camaraderie among its patrons. It’s easy to make new friends over a few laughs and some shared plates. If you’re looking to meet someone special or just enjoy a night out, Bull & Crown offers an experience that’s both fun and inviting. In a city full of history, this bar feels like a timeless escape where connections are just a toast away!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Jacksonville.

Forgotten Tonic

Highlights
Friendly, skilled bartenders
Delicious and festive drinks
Beautifully decorated venue
Amazing food selections
Attentive and helpful service

When it comes to finding a vibrant and welcoming singles bar, Forgotten Tonic in St Augustine crafts an experience that genuinely stands out. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by charming decor that perfectly captures a whimsical yet cozy atmosphere. You know you're in for a treat when the bartenders are not just friendly but also skilled mixologists! They whip up festive drinks that not only tantalize your taste buds but also create the perfect conversation starter.

As I settled in, I couldn't resist trying some of their amazing food selections. Each bite complemented my drink beautifully, enhancing the lively ambiance around me. The overall service was also attentive and helpful, making it easy to strike up conversations with fellow patrons.

What I appreciated most was the effortless blend of social energy and relaxation within the space. It’s a fantastic spot for singles to mingle, laugh, and connect over a shared love of creative cocktails and mouthwatering bites. If you're in St Augustine and seeking a bar that offers both fun and flavor, I wholeheartedly recommend checking out Forgotten Tonic. Your new favorite spot may just be waiting for you!

You might also want to check out the best club in Jacksonville.

Trade Winds Lounge

At Trade Winds Lounge, the vibe is effortlessly inviting, perfect for those looking to spark a connection. The dim lighting and eclectic decorations create a cozy atmosphere that's both charming and comfortable. I found the crowd to be a delightful mix of locals and visitors, all drawn together by the promise of good company and refreshing cocktails. The bartenders are friendly and skilled, crafting drinks that not only taste great but also serve as perfect icebreakers. Whether you're challenging someone to a game of pool or enjoying live music, this spot is a must-visit for singles seeking a fun night out!

You might also want to check out the best night clubs in Jacksonville.

Prohibition Kitchen

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Prohibition Kitchen is an absolute gem for singles seeking a vibrant atmosphere. With its industrial-chic decor and welcoming vibe, the bar sets the perfect stage for striking up conversations. I was instantly captivated by their artisanal cocktails, which are as delicious as they are inventive. The lively music creates an inviting backdrop, while the friendly staff adds to the warmth. Whether you’re unwinding after work or looking for a weekend adventure, this spot offers a fantastic mix of fun and social connection. Don’t miss the chance to mingle here!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in St Augustine.

Mill Top Tavern and Listening Room

Mill Top Tavern and Listening Room is a delightful gem for singles in St Augustine. With its rustic charm and lively atmosphere, I felt instantly at ease. The exposed brick walls and high ceilings set a perfect backdrop for mingling. The live music was a fantastic touch, providing an engaging soundtrack for conversation. I noticed that the crowd was friendly and open, making it easy to strike up a chat over a delicious craft cocktail. If you're looking to connect with like-minded souls while enjoying a vibrant setting, this tavern is a must-visit! Cheers to new connections!

You might also want to check out the best breweries in Jacksonville.

Muggsy’s

Muggsy’s is a delightful gem tucked away in St Augustine, brimming with character and charm. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a lively atmosphere, perfect for mingling. The extensive drink menu offers an array of cocktails that are as playful as the crowd. I loved the friendly bartenders, who were quick to strike up a conversation, making it easy to connect with fellow patrons. With its vibrant ambiance and cozy seating, Muggsy’s is an ideal spot for singles looking to spark a connection. If you're seeking fun and flirtation, don’t miss out on this place!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville Beach.

Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen is a delightful haven for singles looking to mingle. The ambiance is vibrant, with quirky decor that sparks conversation and invites laughter. Their cocktail menu is nothing short of inventive—each drink feels like a work of art! The friendly staff creates a welcoming atmosphere, encouraging a sense of community among patrons. I found the music selection perfectly curated, setting the tone for fun interactions. If you're on the hunt for a relaxed vibe and opportunities to connect, Odd Birds is the perfect perch!

You might also want to check out the best brewery in St Augustine.

Pierre's Pub

Stepping into Pierre's Pub felt like entering a lively embrace. This charming spot has an inviting atmosphere that buzzes with excitement, perfect for singles looking to mingle. With its cozy booths and vibrant decor, it's easy to strike up a conversation with fellow fun-seekers. The drink menu boasts an impressive selection, and the friendly bartenders know how to whip up a delightful cocktail that eases any first-date jitters. Live music adds a delightful touch, creating an engaging backdrop for potential connections. If you’re on the hunt for love, Pierre's Pub might just be your next favorite haunt!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in St Augustine.

Ice Plant Bar

Located in a beautifully restored 1920s ice plant, Ice Plant Bar combines a unique ambiance with a vibrant crowd, ideal for singles. The flair of craft cocktails—each expertly made with house-infused ingredients—invites conversation and camaraderie. I found the atmosphere lively yet intimate, perfect for sparking connections. The rustic décor, paired with knowledgeable staff, creates an inviting environment that encourages mingling. If you’re looking to meet someone new while sipping on a delectable drink, this bar deserves a top spot on your list. Don't miss their signature cocktails; they might just be the key to breaking the ice!

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Jacksonville.