St Augustine's Best Drinks [Updated 2025]

Trust me, I’ve sipped my way through St. Augustine, uncovering hidden gems and popular hangouts alike. After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say that this city knows how to pour a perfect drink. Whether you're in the mood for a refreshing cocktail by the waterfront or a cozy craft brew in a tucked-away pub, I’ve got the lowdown on where to go.

As someone who’s called this historic city home for years, I’ve developed a keen palate and an eye for quality, and I can’t wait to guide you through the vibrant flavors and unique atmospheres that St. Augustine has to offer. Let’s dive into the delicious drinks that make this place so special!

The Tini Martini Bar

Highlights
Speakeasy atmosphere
Extensive martini selection
Live music adds charm
Friendly staff experience
Quick service during off-peak

At The Tini Martini Bar, I was immediately enchanted by the speakeasy atmosphere that exudes an air of nostalgia and charm. The dimly lit space is decorated with vintage touches, making it the perfect backdrop for enjoying a cocktail in style. I was impressed by their extensive martini selection—it felt like stepping into a world of flavor possibilities! I couldn't resist trying the Key Lime Pie Martini, a delightful twist that was both refreshing and dessert-like, leaving me yearning for another sip.

As I sipped my cocktail, the ambiance was further elevated by live music wafting through the venue, enhancing the overall experience. The friendly staff were not just efficient but also genuinely passionate about their craft, offering recommendations with enthusiasm and warmth.

Even during what seemed to be an off-peak hour, my drink arrived swiftly, demonstrating their commitment to quick service without compromising quality. With an inviting vibe, diverse drink options, and attentive service, The Tini Martini Bar stands out in St Augustine as a must-visit for anyone seeking an exceptional cocktail experience. It's a place where every sip feels like a celebration!

You might also want to check out the best bars in St Augustine.

Forgotten Tonic

Highlights
Festive and delicious drinks
Friendly, skilled bartenders
Amazing food and service
Beautifully decorated venue
Must-try spot in St. Augustine

Forgotten Tonic Review

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Forgotten Tonic is a hidden gem that has quickly become one of my favorite spots for festive and delicious drinks. Upon entering, the beautifully decorated venue immediately captivates you, setting the stage for a memorable evening. The ambiance is enchanting, blending charm with a hint of nostalgia—a perfect reflection of St. Augustine's spirit.

What truly elevates the experience here are the friendly, skilled bartenders. They are not just mixing drinks; they're crafting concoctions that dance on your palate. I savored their signature cocktail, which was an intricate blend of floral notes and citrus zest, leaving me craving just one more sip. Each visit has been complemented by amazing food that pairs beautifully with the drink selection—it's not just a bar but a full experience.

If you're wandering through this historic city, make sure Forgotten Tonic is on your list. It's a must-try spot that promises both delightful beverages and exceptional hospitality. So, don your explorer hat and prepare for a delightful escape; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville.

Cap's On the Water

Highlights
Beautiful sunset views
Friendly and efficient service
Casual and spacious atmosphere
Excellent seafood options
Great for family gatherings

Cap's On the Water is a hidden gem that truly encapsulates the essence of St Augustine. Nestled along the picturesque waterside, it offers spectacular sunset views that create a magical backdrop for any gathering. As I settled in with a cold drink, I was immediately struck by the friendly and efficient service from the staff, who made me feel right at home.

The atmosphere is wonderfully casual and spacious, making it perfect for both family gatherings and a laid-back evening out with friends. I began my evening with their signature cocktail, and let me tell you, the flavors danced on my palate! With a selection of delightful seafood options that perfectly paired with my drink, it’s no wonder this place is a local favorite.

As the sun dipped below the horizon, transforming the sky into a kaleidoscope of colors, I found myself utterly enchanted. If you're on the hunt for the best drinks in St Augustine, Cap's On the Water is a place you'll want to visit. It’s an experience that goes beyond just drinks; it’s about savoring the moment in the stunning coastal ambiance. Cheers! 🍹✨

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in Jacksonville.

Boat Drinks

Highlights
Authentic, non-touristy vibe
Friendly and knowledgeable staff
Delicious smash burger
Flavorful plantains platter
A must-stop for drinks

Boat Drinks is an unexpected gem nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, where the atmosphere feels as friendly as a warm summer breeze. Upon entering, you're greeted by an authentic, non-touristy vibe that sets the stage for an unforgettable experience. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and eager to guide you through their delightful drink menu.

I opted for a refreshing cocktail that perfectly complemented my surroundings, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The blend of flavors was vibrant, refreshing, and utterly delightful. Boat Drinks is not just about the drinks, though. Their smash burger deserves a shout-out; it’s a delicious masterpiece that pairs beautifully with any beverage.

And if you’re in the mood for something a bit more unique, definitely try their plantains platter. It’s flavorful and a wonderful conversation starter at the table. Boat Drinks is a spot I wholeheartedly recommend; it’s a must-stop for anyone seeking to enjoy the best beverages in St. Augustine. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this place will win your heart — one drink at a time!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in Jacksonville.

Ice Plant Bar

My recent visit to Ice Plant Bar in St. Augustine was a delightful journey into the world of mixology. The artisanal cocktails here are not just drinks; they’re crafted masterpieces. I savored the whimsical flavor of their signature gin and tonic, where house-made tonic adds an intriguing twist. The ambiance, a charming blend of vintage and modern, sets the perfect stage for sipping. The staff? Exceptionally knowledgeable and genuinely passionate about their creations. If you’re seeking a spot where every sip tells a story, Ice Plant Bar should absolutely be on your radar. Cheers to unforgettable moments!

You might also want to check out the best club in Jacksonville.

Prohibition Kitchen

At Prohibition Kitchen, the spirited ambiance perfectly complements their creative cocktail menu. I savored the signature ‘Pisco Sour’, a delightful blend of Peruvian pisco, fresh lime, and egg white—smooth with a frothy finish. The drink's vibrant citrus notes danced on my palate, reminiscent of sunny days. I also indulged in the ‘Smoky Old Fashioned’, where the infusion of hickory wood added a captivating complexity. The bartenders took their craft seriously, blending flavors with artistry. If you're seeking a place where vintage charm meets innovative mixology, look no further—Prohibition Kitchen is a must-visit! Cheers!

You might also want to check out the best night clubs in Jacksonville.

Trade Winds Lounge

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, Trade Winds Lounge is a delightful oasis for cocktail lovers. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that instantly set the stage for my tasting adventure. I opted for their signature Mango Mojito, an invigorating blend that danced on my palate with fresh mint and zesty lime. Each sip was a refreshing escape, perfectly balanced and oh-so-refreshing. The attentive staff added to the experience, making sure my glass was never empty. If you’re in search of an exotic drink that captures the essence of this charming city, look no further!

You might also want to check out the best happy hour in St Augustine.

Mill Top Tavern and Listening Room

Nestled among the historic charm of St. Augustine, Mill Top Tavern and Listening Room offers an intoxicating blend of ambiance and libations. I savored their signature mojito, which boasted fresh mint and just the right amount of zing—perfect for a warm Florida evening. The live music added a delightful backdrop, creating an inviting atmosphere to sip and sway. Don’t miss their craft beers on tap; the local selections were a particular highlight. If you're seeking a spot that perfectly marries great drinks with a vibrant scene, look no further than this charming tavern! 🍹🎶

You might also want to check out the best breweries in Jacksonville.

The Drunken Horse St. Augustine

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, The Drunken Horse serves up an eclectic mix of flavors that delighted my palate. I savored their signature Horse’s Neigh, a refreshing twist on a classic mojito, perfectly balancing mint and lime with a hint of rum. The ambiance is vibrant, capturing the city's spirited essence, and the staff exudes genuine hospitality that makes you feel right at home. Don't miss their creative craft beer selection, featuring local brews that pair wonderfully with their lively atmosphere. If you're in search of a unique drink experience, The Drunken Horse is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best bars in Jacksonville Beach.

Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen

Since I'm an expert reviewer of drinks, I recently visited Odd Birds Cocktail Lounge and Kitchen in St Augustine, and it was a delightful adventure! This charming spot blends playfulness with craftsmanship, showcasing a menu full of inventive cocktails. I was particularly captivated by the Tropical Tiki—a vibrant concoction that danced upon my palate with notes of pineapple and rum. The atmosphere was equally enchanting, with its quirky decor and welcoming vibe. If you’re searching for a place that delivers both fantastic drinks and a unique experience, Odd Birds is a must-visit. Cheers to sipping artfully crafted cocktails in good company!

You might also want to check out the best brewery in St Augustine.

Pierre's Pub

Stepping into Pierre's Pub feels like a warm embrace from a cozy friend. The craft cocktails sparkle like jewels, but the standout for me was the Blood Orange Mojito. Its tart yet refreshing flavor danced on my palate, making it absolutely delightful. The laid-back vibe, accentuated by friendly bartenders and local artwork, creates an inviting atmosphere. I also savored their eclectic selection of local beers, perfect for the craft beer aficionado. If you're exploring St Augustine, don’t miss this gem—a spot where great drinks and charming company await! Cheers to good times at Pierre’s!

You might also want to check out the best sports bars in St Augustine.

Sarbez!

Sarbez! is an eclectic gem that beautifully blends a laid-back vibe with a vibrant drink scene. Their craft cocktails are a delightful surprise; I savored a refreshing Cucumber Mint Mojito that danced on my palate with every sip. The adult slushies are a playful twist on childhood favorites, perfect for the warm Florida sun. The venue's walls, adorned with quirky art, create an inviting atmosphere while you sip on your drink. Whether you're a local or a visitor, don’t miss the chance to unwind at Sarbez!—it’s where great flavors and fun collide!

You might also want to check out the best liquor store in Jacksonville.