St Augustine's Best Realtor [Updated 2025]

Navigating the real estate market can feel like wandering through a maze, especially in a charming city like St. Augustine. After diving deep into the local scene and reviewing 12 top realtors, I’ve uncovered the standout professionals who truly shine in this historic town.

Having spent years exploring the ins and outs of St. Augustine, I’ve developed a keen eye for what makes a realtor not just good, but exceptional. Whether you’re buying your first home or seeking the perfect investment property, it’s essential to have someone who understands both the market and the unique character of this beautiful city by your side. Let’s find that perfect fit together!

DJ & Lindsey Real Estate

Highlights
Outstanding communication
Above and beyond service
Seamless closing coordination
Expert guidance throughout
Highly recommended agent

During my visit to DJ & Lindsey Real Estate, I was delighted by the level of outstanding communication that truly sets them apart. From the very first interaction, I found the team to be exceptionally responsive, ensuring that no question went unanswered. It's not every day that you encounter real estate agents who genuinely invest their time and energy into their clients, but DJ and Lindsey do just that!

What impressed me most was their commitment to providing above-and-beyond service at every stage of the buying or selling process. They make what can be an overwhelming journey feel seamless and enjoyable. Their expert guidance kept me well-informed and confident when navigating the real estate landscape in St Augustine.

Closing felt like a breeze, thanks to their meticulous attention to detail and seamless closing coordination. I felt like I had a supportive ally every step of the way. If you’re searching for a highly recommended agent who knows the ins and outs of the local market, I wholeheartedly suggest giving DJ & Lindsey a call. They might just make your real estate dreams come true in this beautiful historic town!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in St Augustine.

Belinda Ravan, Broker-Associate

Highlights
Lifelong local expertise
Excellent communication
Proactive and fun negotiator
Above and beyond service
Rock star in real estate

Review of Belinda Ravan, Broker-Associate in St Augustine

From the moment I met Belinda Ravan, it was clear that her lifelong local expertise sets her apart in the bustling market of St Augustine. Amidst the vibrant historic streets and stunning coastal views, Belinda stood out as a true guardian of the charming community. Her excellent communication skills transformed what could have been a daunting process into a delightful journey.

Belinda’s approach to negotiation is refreshing; she’s not just proactive, but she brings a playful spirit to the table that makes dealing with contracts and offers feel less like business and more like collaborating with a friend. She truly goes above and beyond, and that service reflects in every detail she handles.

What I found most impressive is her knack for turning challenges into opportunities—a rock star in the realm of real estate! With her keen insight and unwavering support, every client is bound to feel well-cared for. If you’re looking for a realtor with a combination of professional prowess and a dash of fun, look no further than Belinda Ravan. She'll make your home buying experience in St Augustine unforgettable!

You might also want to check out the best malls in Jacksonville.

For Buyers Only Realty

Highlights
Exceptional customer service
Knowledgeable and reliable team
Strong negotiation skills
Smooth and stress-free process
Excellent communication

When it comes to finding the right realtor in St Augustine, For Buyers Only Realty truly stands out from the crowd! From the moment I walked through the door, I was greeted by a team that exudes exceptional customer service. They make you feel like family, and it's clear that their passion for helping buyers shines through.

The knowledgeable team is incredibly reliable, guiding you through every step of the process. Their strong negotiation skills are impressive; they really know how to champion your interests while maintaining a friendly demeanor. I found the entire experience to be remarkably smooth and stress-free—no hidden agendas or pesky surprises!

What struck me most was their communication. For Buyers Only Realty keeps you in the loop, ensuring that you never feel lost in the process. We all know how overwhelming buying a home can be, but thanks to their expertise, I felt empowered and informed every step of the way.

If you’re on the hunt for a realtor who combines professionalism with a personal touch, look no further! For Buyers Only Realty is a fantastic choice for anyone eager to navigate the beautiful St Augustine real estate market. 🌟

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Jacksonville.

TEAM Territo at Keller Williams Atlantic Partners St. Augustine

Highlights
Exceptional client experience
Knowledgeable and attentive team
Strong marketing and photography
Patience and understanding
Community-focused events

Visiting TEAM Territo at Keller Williams Atlantic Partners St. Augustine was nothing short of delightful! ⭐ From the moment I walked through the door, I felt a sense of warmth and professionalism that is often hard to find in the real estate world. The team's exceptional client experience truly sets them apart. They take the time to listen and understand your needs, making the buying or selling process not just a transaction, but a personal journey.

Their knowledgeable and attentive team is incredibly impressive; I could see why so many locals recommend them! Each member brings a unique skill set, but they all share a common goal – to ensure you feel valued and supported. 📊 The marketing and photography they use are nothing short of outstanding, making properties shine like new stars on the real estate stage.

What I appreciated most was their patience and understanding throughout my visits. They don’t rush you; instead, they empower you to make informed decisions. Plus, they really embrace the community, often participating in local events, which reflects their genuine passion for St Augustine. If you’re seeking a realtor who blends savvy with sincerity, look no further than TEAM Territo – they are, quite frankly, the best in town! 🏡✨

You might also want to check out the best dispensaries in Jacksonville.

The Newcomer Group

Highlights
Outstanding professionalism
Strong communication and transparency
Efficient and timely process
Treat clients like family
Commitment to long-term relationships

When it comes to finding a realtor in St Augustine, The Newcomer Group truly stands out from the crowd. From my very first interaction, it was clear that their professionalism was top-notch. Every member of the team exuded a warm, friendly vibe, making me feel like I was joining an extended family rather than just a business transaction.

Their strong communication set them apart; I was never left in the dark about the process or next steps. It was refreshing to see such transparency, allowing me to trust them with my real estate needs wholeheartedly. Not to mention, the process was remarkably efficient and timely, which is a virtue in the often chaotic world of property buying and selling.

What truly impressed me was their commitment to building long-term relationships with clients. They don’t just assist you in finding a home; they genuinely want to see you thrive in your new environment. All in all, The Newcomer Group knows how to blend professionalism with a personal touch. If you’re looking for a realtor who treats you like family while delivering stellar service, look no further!

You might also want to check out the best food in St Augustine.

Welch Team - Keller Williams Realty

Highlights
Highly recommended expertise
Patient and understanding team
Supportive during challenges
Professional and kind service
Trusted guidance throughout

When it comes to navigating the St. Augustine real estate scene, the Welch Team - Keller Williams Realty truly stands out. From the moment I stepped into their office, I felt an undeniable sense of warmth and professionalism that instantly put me at ease. Their highly recommended expertise in the local market is not just a title; it's a badge they wear with pride.

What I particularly appreciated was their patient and understanding nature. Buying or selling a home can feel overwhelming, but the Welch team excels at providing supportive guidance through each twist and turn. Whenever I faced challenges, they remained a steady anchor, always ready with solutions and encouragement.

Additionally, their service is imbued with a unique blend of kindness and professionalism. Every interaction felt genuine, as if they truly cared about my needs and aspirations. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a seasoned seller, their trusted guidance helps demystify real estate, making the process enjoyable rather than daunting.

In short, if you’re looking for the best realtor in St. Augustine, I wholeheartedly recommend the Welch Team. Their dedication not only helps clients find their dream homes but also cultivates lasting relationships built on trust and support!

You might also want to check out the best park in Jacksonville.

Andrew Butler

Highlights
Fantastic buying process
Excellent local area knowledge
Timely and successful closings
Highly recommended by clients
Trustworthy and reliable realtor

Andrew Butler is quite the gem in the bustling realm of St. Augustine real estate! My journey with him was nothing short of delightful. From the very first interaction, I felt I was in the hands of a true professional. The buying process was as smooth as a gentle breeze off the Matanzas River—timely and successful closings seemed to follow Andrew wherever he went!

What truly sets Andrew apart is his excellent local area knowledge. He knows St. Augustine like the back of his hand, which proved invaluable when discussing potential neighborhoods. Whether you’re curious about the quaint cobblestone streets or the vibrant local culture, Andrew has insights that make you feel right at home even before you settle in.

Moreover, the enthusiastic recommendations from his clients echo his trustworthiness and reliability. It's clear that he’s not just about making a sale; he genuinely wants to help you find that perfect slice of paradise. If you're searching for a realtor who's both playful and professional, look no further than Andrew. He’s not just a realtor; he’s an experience, a guide, and perhaps even your future neighbor!

You might also want to check out the best used car dealerships in Jacksonville.

Keller Williams Atlantic Partners St. Augustine

Highlights
Expert in Buying and Selling
Professional and Responsive Agent
Quick Transaction Closures
Knowledgeable Staff
Excellent Client Resources

Keller Williams Atlantic Partners St. Augustine is truly a shining star in the realm of real estate! From the moment I stepped into their welcoming office, I was greeted by a team of professional and responsive agents who clearly know their stuff. One standout aspect is their commitment to clients, making every interaction feel personal and significant.

As someone who has observed the buying and selling game, I must say that the agents at Keller Williams excel in both arenas. They have that rare knack for turning potential transactions into smooth sailing, often resulting in quick transaction closures. It's impressive how they navigate the intricacies of the market with such confidence.

The staff's knowledge is another feather in their cap. They patiently answered all my questions, showcasing their expertise and ensuring I felt informed. Plus, the array of client resources they offer gives buyers and sellers an edge in their quests.

In short, if you're on the lookout for a dedicated team that prioritizes your needs while guiding you through the ups and downs of real estate, Keller Williams Atlantic Partners St. Augustine should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best divorce attorney in Jacksonville.

Watson Realty Corp St. Augustine

Highlights
Professional and knowledgeable
Trustworthy and reliable advice
Patient and friendly service
Local area expertise
Highly recommended by clients

Review of Watson Realty Corp St. Augustine

When I strolled into Watson Realty Corp St. Augustine, I knew I was walking into a haven of professionalism and expertise. The team instantly radiated a sense of trust, making me feel like I was in good hands. What stood out to me was their deep understanding of the local market; it was clear that they had their finger on the pulse of what makes St. Augustine unique.

Throughout my interactions, I found their service to be both patient and thoroughly friendly. Whether I had a simple question or a complex query, they took the time to ensure I understood every detail. It’s not often you come across a realtor that genuinely cares about finding the right fit for their clients rather than just closing a deal.

Their reputation among clients is a testament to their commitment; highly recommended seems like an understatement! If you’re searching for a partner in real estate that combines trustworthiness with expertise, Watson Realty Corp St. Augustine is a standout choice in this beautiful city!

You might also want to check out the best plumber in Jacksonville.

Jeremy Taylor, REALTOR | River + Coast Property Group | MAXREV

Highlights
Fantastic realtor experience
Extensive market knowledge
Quick home selling process
Excellent communication skills
Patient and thorough guidance

From my very first interaction with Jeremy Taylor, I knew I was in capable hands. His fantastic realtor experience was evident as he guided me through the home buying process with a playful yet professional demeanor. What struck me most was his extensive market knowledge—he seemed to have all the ins and outs of the St Augustine area at his fingertips.

When it comes to selling homes, Jeremy has mastered brevity without sacrificing quality; the process was quick and efficient, alleviating typical stress. Every question I had was met with prompt and comprehensive answers—his excellent communication skills really stood out, making me feel valued and informed at every step.

What truly sets Jeremy apart is his patient and thorough guidance. It’s refreshing to work with someone who never rushes you into decisions, taking the time to truly understand your needs. If you’re seeking a realtor who combines expertise with a personable touch, look no further than Jeremy Taylor. He’s not just a realtor; he’s a partner in what can often be an overwhelming experience. I wholeheartedly recommend him for anyone looking to navigate the St Augustine real estate market.

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Jacksonville.

St Augustine Realty

St Augustine Realty truly shone during my visit! Their dedicated team exudes professionalism while remaining approachable. I was impressed by their in-depth knowledge of the local market and their ability to connect clients with exactly what they need. Every interaction felt like working with friends rather than just agents. They take pride in their personalized service, ensuring no question goes unanswered. The office atmosphere is both welcoming and vibrant, making the entire house-hunting journey a joy. If you're searching for a reliable partner in St Augustine, you won’t be disappointed with St Augustine Realty! 🏡✨

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Jacksonville.

Noah Bailey Group | Keller Williams Realty St. Augustine

From the moment I stepped into the Noah Bailey Group | Keller Williams Realty St. Augustine, I felt a warm welcome that set the tone for a fantastic experience. Their team is not just knowledgeable but genuinely passionate about finding the perfect homes for their clients. Noah himself is a master negotiator, and his enthusiasm is contagious! They have a treasure trove of local insights, making them a reliable ally in the bustling St. Augustine market. If you’re on the hunt for your dream home, I wholeheartedly recommend giving them a call—you're in for a delightful journey!

You might also want to check out the best criminal lawyer in Jacksonville.