St Augustine's Best Thrift Stores [Updated 2025]

Each shop holds a treasure trove of unique finds, from vintage clothing to quirky home decor that you never knew you needed. After exploring 12 of the top thrift stores in this charming city, I’ve gathered insights that go beyond just prices and locations.

Trust me, I know my way around a thrift store like the back of my hand! I’ve sifted through racks and rummaged through bins, all in the pursuit of the perfect piece that tells a story. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or just looking to snag a unique souvenir, my guide will help you uncover the best spots to score those one-of-a-kind treasures. Let’s dive in!

Haven -- St. Augustine Attic Resale Store

Highlights
Quality goods and great prices
Supports local hospice services
Well organized and clean
Daily sales and $1 clothing rack
Unique finds and high-end items

Haven – St. Augustine Attic Resale Store is truly a hidden gem in the heart of St. Augustine! From the moment I walked in, I was charmed by its neat organization and inviting atmosphere. This thrift store is a delightful blend of quality goods at fantastic prices. I especially appreciated the $1 clothing rack, which felt like unlocking a treasure chest of wardrobe possibilities!

One of the standout features is that all the proceeds support local hospice services, which adds a heartwarming layer to your shopping experience. Browsing through a mix of unique finds and high-end items, I felt like a savvy treasure hunter uncovering gems among the shelves. The daily sales are a fantastic bonus for anyone looking to snag a deal.

Every corner of Haven was enriched by a sense of community, operating in a way that encourages patrons to give back while enjoying some retail therapy. It was refreshing to soak in the vibe of a store that’s not just about the goods, but about making a difference. If you're in St. Augustine and love thrift shopping, don’t miss out on this charming spot—your next great find awaits!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Jacksonville.

Alpha-Omega Thrift Store

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Highly organized and clean
New items every week
Supports a good cause
Ample free parking

Stepping into Alpha-Omega Thrift Store is like entering a treasure trove of delightful discoveries! The moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly and welcoming staff—you can immediately tell they genuinely enjoy what they do. The store itself is highly organized and clean, making it easy to navigate through the aisles without feeling overwhelmed.

What truly sets Alpha-Omega apart is their commitment to bringing in new items every week. I found everything from vintage clothing to quirky home décor, and I couldn't help but smile as I unearthed unique finds that felt like they had a story to tell. Plus, shopping here supports a good cause, which makes each purchase feel like a step toward making a positive impact in the community.

With ample free parking available, it’s a breeze to stop by anytime you’re in the area. If you’re hoping to uncover some gems or simply indulge your thrift store passion, Alpha-Omega is a must-visit destination. You won’t just leave with a special find—you'll also take home a warm feeling from supporting a meaningful cause. Happy thrifting!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in St Augustine.

Around We Go Children's Consignment & Equipment Rentals

Highlights
Well-organized store
Fantastic selection of items
Unbeatable prices
Friendly and helpful staff
Online purchase option available

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, Around We Go Children's Consignment & Equipment Rentals is a delightful treasure trove for parents and kids alike. I was instantly charmed by the well-organized layout of the store, which makes browsing a joyful experience. From gently used toys to adorable outfits for every season, this shop boasts a fantastic selection of items that brings a smile to even the weariest shopper.

What truly stands out at Around We Go is the unbeatable pricing. Each item is reasonably marked, allowing families to stock up on essentials without breaking the bank. I lost track of time as I sifted through the aisles, each section seemingly bursting with potential finds. To top it all off, the staff was exceptionally friendly and helpful, always ready with a smile and assistance if needed.

One feature worth noting is their online purchase option, which is a godsend for busy parents. This place really encapsulates the spirit of thrift shopping—finding rare gems and great deals while supporting local businesses. If you’re in the area, I wholeheartedly recommend visiting. Trust me, it’s an experience that will leave you looking forward to your next visit!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Jacksonville.

Aunt Matilda's Steampunk Trunk

Highlights
Unique steampunk creations
Friendly and helpful staff
Wide variety of decorations
Nostalgic and artistic vibe
Engaging tarot card selection

Aunt Matilda's Steampunk Trunk offers a whimsical blend of nostalgia and creativity that feels like stepping into another world. Upon entering, you’re greeted by a friendly and helpful staff who invite you to explore their eclectic collection of steampunk treasures. I could hardly contain my excitement as I navigated through the aisles, marveling at the unique steampunk creations that adorned the space—from intricately designed goggles to vintage-inspired jewelry.

What truly sets Aunt Matilda's apart is the wide variety of decorations available. Whether you’re searching for the perfect conversation starter for your home or a quirky gift for a friend, you’re bound to find something that captures your imagination. The atmosphere is nothing short of magical, with an artistic vibe that inspires creativity. I found myself pondering how to incorporate their beautiful items into my own décor.

But the treasures don’t stop there! Dive into a selection of engaging tarot cards that beckon the spiritually curious. Overall, Aunt Matilda's Steampunk Trunk is a delightful destination for anyone who appreciates the peculiar and the extraordinary. If you're in St Augustine, this charming thrift store is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best park in Jacksonville.

Orange Blossom Consignment Boutique

Stepping into Orange Blossom Consignment Boutique is like entering a treasure trove of unique finds! This charming store is adorned with an eclectic mix of clothing, accessories, and home decor that truly captures the spirit of St Augustine. I was particularly impressed by the welcoming atmosphere and the friendly staff, who are always eager to help. The prices are surprisingly reasonable, making it easy to stroll away with delightful goodies without breaking the bank. Don't miss the vintage gems tucked away in corners—each one tells a story! If you're a thrifting enthusiast, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best companies to work for in Jacksonville.

Cool and Collected Vintage & Antiques

During my visit to Cool and Collected Vintage & Antiques, I was instantly charmed by its eclectic selection and whimsical ambiance. From retro clothing to elegant vintage furniture, this treasure trove offers something for every collector and thrifter. The friendly staff were not only knowledgeable but also passionate about their unique finds. I stumbled upon some irresistible mid-century pieces that practically begged to come home with me. It’s a delightful journey through time, making every corner worth exploring. If you’re in St Augustine, don’t miss this gem—it’s truly a paradise for vintage enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best chicken wings in Jacksonville.

Betty Griffin Center Thrift Store

Tucked away in a charming corner of St Augustine, the Betty Griffin Center Thrift Store is a delightful treasure trove. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by friendly staff and an eclectic mix of items just waiting to be discovered. The selection ranges from vintage clothing to quirky home decor, making it a perfect stop for both collectors and casual shoppers. Plus, every purchase supports a worthy cause, enhancing the feel-good factor! If you’re on the hunt for unique finds and a touch of community spirit, this store is a must-visit gem in the heart of the city.

You might also want to check out the best shopping in St Augustine.

Twice the Charm

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Twice the Charm is a treasure trove for thrift enthusiasts! 🎉 The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a delightful mix of vintage finds and quirky knick-knacks. The bright, inviting atmosphere invites you to browse leisurely. I discovered everything from charming furniture to chic clothing, all at unbeatable prices! What truly caught my eye were the unique home decor pieces that added a special touch to my collection. If you're hunting for rare gems or just looking to enjoy a whimsical shopping experience, Twice the Charm is a must-visit! 🌟

You might also want to check out the best furniture store in Jacksonville.

Fifi's Fine Resale Apparel of St Augustine

Stepping into Fifi's Fine Resale Apparel felt like entering a treasure chest of fashion! This chic boutique offers a delightful assortment of gently-used designer clothing and accessories, all carefully curated for the stylish shopper. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it easy to spend hours rifling through racks filled with unique finds. I was particularly thrilled by the exceptional prices—who knew luxury could be so affordable? Whether you're searching for a statement piece or a cozy outfit, Fifi's has it all. Don’t miss this gem; it’s a true haven for thrift enthusiasts in St Augustine!

You might also want to check out the best home builders in Jacksonville.

S.A.F.E. Pet Rescue and Thrift Store

Visiting S.A.F.E. Pet Rescue and Thrift Store was a delightful adventure! This charming treasure trove not only offers a fabulous selection of vintage wares and quirky finds but also supports a noble cause—helping pets in need. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with staff that radiate enthusiasm and dedication. I was particularly taken by the curated clothing racks and unique home goods that promised a story behind each piece. It’s a delightful spot to discover gems while contributing to a wonderful mission. If you’re in St Augustine, you can’t miss this thrilling stop for thrifty shopping!

You might also want to check out the best christmas lights in Jacksonville.

Graet Goods

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, Graet Goods is a treasure trove waiting to be discovered! The moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a delightful array of vintage finds and eclectic home decor. From quirky clothing to stunning antiques, the selection is impressive. The staff is friendly and eager to help, making the shopping experience enjoyable. I particularly loved the sense of community they've cultivated, highlighted by local art displays. If you’re on the hunt for unique gems at great prices, Graet Goods is definitely a must-visit spot in this charming city!

You might also want to check out the best jobs in Jacksonville.

A Coastal Home by Vintage Chic

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, A Coastal Home by Vintage Chic is a treasure trove for those who adore all things coastal and quaint. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by a delightful array of charming decor, vintage finds, and unique artwork that perfectly embodies the area's vibrant spirit. The staff is super friendly, always eager to help you unearth that perfect piece. Whether you’re hunting for coastal decor or a statement vintage item, this shop is an absolute must-visit for any thrift lover. I left with a smile and a delightful new find!

You might also want to check out the best antique stores in Jacksonville.