St Augustine's Best Pasta [Updated 2025]

You’ll find that St. Augustine isn’t just a feast for the eyes with its historic charm; it’s also a culinary treasure trove, especially when it comes to pasta. I’ve taken it upon myself to sample dishes from 12 of the best pasta spots around town, diving fork-first into creamy sauces and al dente perfection.

Why trust my palate? I’ve spent years wandering these cobblestone streets, indulging in every twist and turn of Italian cuisine. My mission is simple: to help you discover the hidden gems and beloved favorites that make this city’s pasta scene truly special. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, get ready to find your new favorite bowl of goodness!

Saint Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Elegant waterfront dining
Impeccable service
Stunning courtyard ambiance
Delicious bread service
Must-try Hundred Layer Lasagna

Saint Italian Restaurant in St Augustine is like stepping into an Italian dream, where the ambiance sings and the pasta dances on your palate. Nestled on the waterfront, the restaurant boasts an elegant dining area that perfectly complements its stunning courtyard ambiance. As I was escorted to my table, I couldn’t help but marvel at the picturesque views of the water, setting the stage for an unforgettable meal.

The service was impeccable—my server was attentive yet unobtrusive, guiding me through the menu with passion and expertise. To start, they served a delightful bread that whisked me away to the heart of Italy with its warm, crusty texture. For the main event, I dove into the must-try Hundred Layer Lasagna, an extravagant masterpiece that truly lives up to its name. Each layer was perfectly cooked, with rich marinara and creamy cheese that melded together in a perfect symphony of flavors.

With its charming atmosphere and exquisite dishes, Saint Italian Restaurant is a must-visit for anyone seeking the best pasta in St Augustine. I left with a heart full of joy and a belly stuffed with deliciousness—what more could one ask for?

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen

Highlights
Best Chicken Marsala
Thin, Crispy Pizza Crust
Authentic Italian Flavors
Delicious Tiramisu Dessert
Friendly Staff and Atmosphere

Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen in St Augustine is a delightful culinary experience that left me craving more. The moment I stepped inside, the warm, inviting atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy Italian embrace. As a true pasta aficionado, I was particularly excited to try their famed Chicken Marsala—a dish that didn’t disappoint. The chicken was tender, oozing with flavor from a perfectly balanced sauce that danced on my palate.

While the pasta was certainly a star, I couldn’t resist sampling the thin, crispy pizza crust. It was a testament to their wood-fired technique, achieving delightful char spots that melded beautifully with fresh toppings. Each bite was a love letter to authenticity, with flavors that transported me straight to Italy.

To top off my meal, I indulged in their delicious tiramisu dessert. It was rich and creamy, a perfect conclusion to an already splendid experience. The friendly staff further enhanced my visit, making me feel like part of their family.

With its authentic Italian flavors and commitment to quality, Simone's truly stands out in St Augustine’s vibrant culinary scene. If you’re a pasta lover, this is one kitchen you can’t afford to miss!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville.

Amici Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Top-notch service experience
Outstanding Italian cuisine
Impressive presentation
Delicious garlic dipping sauce
Chef is well-trained

At Amici Italian Restaurant, I was greeted with a warm ambiance and prompt service that set the tone for my evening. The staff clearly take pride in their craft; you can feel their enthusiasm as they present the outstanding Italian cuisine that graces their menu. Unquestionably, the highlight was the pasta – a genuine celebration of flavors!

I indulged in the handmade fettuccine, which was cooked to perfection, accompanied by a robust marinara sauce that danced on my palate. What truly made my meal shine was the delicious garlic dipping sauce they brought with the freshly baked bread—an absolute must-try! The impressive presentation of each dish showcased the chef's creativity, with vibrant colors and artful plating that made my meal not only delicious but also visually appetizing.

Speaking of the chef, it’s evident that he is well-trained, allowing the flavors to meld flawlessly. Overall, my experience at Amici was delightful—this charming eatery deserves a spot among the best pasta locations in St Augustine. If you’re a pasta enthusiast, don’t miss out on this culinary gem; it’s a food lover’s paradise!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine Beach.

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, Pizzalley's Chianti Room is a delightful culinary retreat. As soon as I entered, the cozy ambiance whispered warmth, setting the stage for the star of the show—their pasta. I indulged in the rich, homemade fettuccine alfredo, where every creamy bite was a luxurious embrace. The flavors danced gracefully, showcasing a perfect balance of garlic and parmesan. Complemented by their hand-selected Chianti, it was a match made in heaven. If you're seeking a memorable pasta experience, look no further—this charming eatery is not to be missed! 🍝 Cheers to extraordinary bites!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Nonnas Trattoria

At Nonnas Trattoria, I found myself immersed in a delightful culinary escape! Their homemade fettuccine alla Alfredo was a creamy masterpiece that danced on my palate, with each bite whispering tales of Italy. The robust flavors of the bolognese sauce reminded me of family gatherings, complete with a hint of nostalgia. The rustic charm of the trattoria, paired with friendly service, made the experience even more enjoyable. If you seek authentic pasta that warms the heart, look no further. Nonnas Trattoria has officially stolen my pasta-loving heart in St Augustine!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Piesanos St Augustine

At Piesanos St Augustine, I dove into a delightful bowl of fettuccine Alfredo that was a creamy symphony of flavors. The pasta was perfectly cooked, and each bite melted in my mouth, inviting me to keep indulging. Their marinara sauce paired with meatballs also had a delightful zing that danced on my palate. The ambiance felt cozy and welcoming—perfect for a casual night out. Overall, Piesanos excels in delivering a genuine pasta experience that left me both satisfied and eager for more. If you’re in search of a comforting pasta dish, this charming eatery is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Poppys Italiano

At Poppys Italiano, I uncovered a delightful haven for pasta lovers. The fettuccine alfredo was a creamy dream, perfectly enveloping each strand with rich flavor and a touch of garlic. Their homemade bolognese sauce—slow-cooked to perfection—was a heavenly balance of spices and meaty goodness that transported me straight to Italy. The warm, inviting atmosphere added to the charm, making it an ideal spot for a cozy dinner. With attentive service and generous portions, Poppys is a charming gem that captures the essence of Italian cuisine, asserting its place among the best pasta destinations in St Augustine.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Casa Benedetto's

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Casa Benedetto's is a culinary gem that radiates charm and warmth. The atmosphere is inviting, making you feel right at home. I couldn't resist diving into their homemade fettuccine alfredo, which danced on my palate with a creamy richness that was simply delightful. Each bite was a melody of flavor, complemented by perfectly sautéed shrimp. The service was impeccable, adding a sprinkle of joy to the experience. If you're on a quest for the best pasta in the city, look no further than Casa Benedetto's—a true celebration of Italian comfort!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Terra & Acqua

Stepping into Terra & Acqua felt like entering a cozy Italian kitchen, where the air was infused with tantalizing aromas. I indulged in their handcrafted tagliatelle, which was a delightful dance of flavors—each bite perfectly al dente and enveloped in a rich, savory sauce. The balance of fresh herbs elevated the dish to a level of pure bliss. Their atmosphere, paired with outstanding service, made the experience even more enjoyable. If you’re seeking authentic pasta bliss in St Augustine, Terra & Acqua should be your next stop!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Sogno Restaurant

At Sogno Restaurant, I felt like I had entered a warm embrace of Italian culinary artistry. Their house-made fettuccine danced elegantly with a rich, creamy Alfredo sauce, while the pesto ravioli sang with vibrant basil flavors. Each bite was a testament to authenticity and passion, leaving me craving more. The ambiance is cozy yet lively, making it an ideal spot for both romance and celebration. To cap it off, the staff exuded warmth, making my meal feel like a personal affair. If you’re in search of exquisite pasta in St Augustine, Sogno is a delightful twist on the classic Italian dream!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Violas

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Violas is a pasta lover’s dream. The moment I entered, the aroma of simmering sauces wrapped around me like a warm hug. I ordered their signature dish, the Fettuccine Alfredo, and every creamy bite was sheer bliss, dancing on my palate. The homemade pasta was expertly cooked to perfection, glistening under a sprinkle of parmesan. The ambiance is charmingly rustic, making it the ideal spot for an intimate dinner or a joyful meal with friends. Don’t miss out on their Tiramisu for dessert—it's the perfect sweet finish to a splendid evening!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

La Cocina at the Cellar Upstairs

Tucked away in the charming streets of St. Augustine, La Cocina at the Cellar Upstairs serves up an irresistible pasta experience. The house-made fettuccine bathed in a velvety marinara sauce was a delectable delight, balancing freshness with rich, robust flavors. Each bite felt like a warm embrace from the culinary gods! The ambiance is intimate, perfect for a cozy dinner or a casual gathering. I particularly savored their gnocchi, which was impossibly light and practically floated off the plate. If you're on the hunt for pasta that sings with authenticity, look no further—this spot truly captures the essence of Italian cuisine!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.