St Augustine's Best Lobster [Updated 2025]

I’ve scoured the charming streets and waterfronts of St. Augustine, indulging in mouthwatering lobster at 12 standout spots. Trust me, I’ve tasted everything from buttery tails to spicy lobster rolls, all in the name of finding the best!

With a palate honed by years of culinary exploration, I’m here to share the secrets behind the freshest, most flavorful lobster dishes this historic city has to offer. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, you’ll want to dive into these delicious recommendations that will have your taste buds dancing. Let’s embark on this tasty adventure together!

Catch 27

Highlights
Elevated dining experience
Craft cocktails perfection
Small, focused menu
Beautiful outdoor seating
Peaceful atmosphere

Catch 27: A Lobster Lover’s Paradise

During my recent culinary adventure in St. Augustine, I found myself ensnared by the charm of Catch 27. Tucked away with its inviting outdoor seating, this gem offers an elevated dining experience where creativity and freshness rule the roost. The moment I settled into the peaceful atmosphere, I knew I was in for a treat.

The menu is small and focused, which makes my heart flutter—a true testament to quality over quantity. The star of my meal? The lobster roll. Served on a buttery, toasted bun, the succulent lobster was perfectly dressed, embracing just the right hint of seasoning that allowed the natural sweetness of the lobster to shine.

Complementing this indulgence were craft cocktails that were nothing short of perfection. Sipping one while savoring each bite made me feel like I was dining at a Michelin-star restaurant rather than a cozy joint in St. Augustine.

Overall, Catch 27 left me craving more after every delightful mouthful. If you find yourself wandering the charming streets of St. Augustine, be sure to stop by—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

O'Steen's Restaurant

Highlights
Hometown favorite restaurant
Best shrimp in town
Delicious hush puppies
Fresh vegetable sides
Super yummy secret sauce

O'Steen's Restaurant is like a warm hug from old Florida—comforting yet exciting. As a self-proclaimed lobster enthusiast, I did not expect to find my muse here amidst the hustle and bustle of seafood offerings. But oh, was I in for a treat!

Upon entering, the ambiance radiates a hometown charm, where locals gather to celebrate fresh ingredients and culinary tradition. While their award-winning shrimp has garnered much praise, the star of my visit was undeniably the lobster, graced with the restaurant's super yummy secret sauce. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, striking a perfect balance between rich and refreshing.

To accompany my dish, I couldn’t resist their delicious hush puppies—think golden bites of pure happiness! Fresh vegetable sides rounded out the meal beautifully, reminding me of sun-soaked days spent on the coast. The vibe here is unpretentious, welcoming you with open arms and entertaining tales from the kitchen.

In my quest for the best lobster in St Augustine, O'Steen's surely made a mark. If you find yourself wandering these picturesque streets, make sure to stop by. Your taste buds will thank you for it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville.

Cap's On the Water

Highlights
Beautiful sunset views
Friendly and efficient staff
Casual and spacious atmosphere
Delicious seafood options
Excellent service experience

Cap's On the Water is nothing short of a hidden gem that effortlessly combines ambiance with delectable dishes. Nestled along the picturesque coastline, the restaurant's breathtaking sunset views are worth the visit alone. As I settled into my seat, the friendly and efficient staff welcomed me with warm smiles, setting the stage for a delightful culinary adventure.

Now, let’s talk about the lobster! The seafood options are nothing short of exceptional, and the lobster stole the show. It arrived grilled to perfection, moist, and bursting with flavor, complemented by a zesty drawn butter that made each bite an absolute pleasure. The casual and spacious atmosphere only added to the experience, making me feel right at home while indulging in some of the finest seafood St Augustine has to offer.

What truly impressed me was the service; every dish was delivered promptly without sacrificing quality. My evening at Cap's On the Water was not just a meal—it was an experience. If you find yourself in St Augustine with a craving for lobster, do yourself a favor and make your way to this culinary paradise. You won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine Beach.

River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge

Highlights
Incredible date night venue
Stunning rooftop views
Friendly and attentive service
Delicious cocktails available
Great atmosphere for everyone

As I stepped into River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge, I was immediately captivated by its charming ambiance, perfect for a special date night or a lively gathering with friends. The breathtaking views from the rooftop added a delightful backdrop to this culinary adventure.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the lobster! I ordered their renowned Lobster Roll, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The luscious lobster was perfectly seasoned and generously piled onto a toasted, buttery roll—a divine combination of flavors and textures. Each bite delivered a satisfying crunch followed by a succulent explosion of ocean-fresh goodness.

The service was equally impressive; the staff was not just friendly but also attentive, ensuring that my dining experience was nothing short of excellent. And let’s not forget about the delicious cocktails that complemented my meal beautifully.

If you find yourself in St Augustine and are on the hunt for the best lobster, make sure to stop by River & Fort. With its charming atmosphere and delectable offerings, it’s a must-visit destination for any food lover!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Outer Banks Boil Company St Augustine

Highlights
Incredible seafood experience
Perfectly cooked, flavorful
Seamless setup, no fuss
Great for family gatherings
Highly recommended seasoning

Stepping into the Outer Banks Boil Company St Augustine, I immediately sensed the promise of an incredible seafood experience. This place isn’t just about lobster; it’s about creating a memorable feast. The ambiance is welcoming, making it perfect for family gatherings or even casual dining with friends.

Now, let’s talk lobster. The moment I took my first bite, I was greeted with exquisite flavors that danced on my palate. Cooked to perfection, the lobster was succulent, with just the right amount of seasoning that elevated the dish without overpowering it. The staff here really nailed that balance, making each bite a delight.

What I loved most was the seamless setup—no fuss, no pretense. You can dig right into your meal with a sense of camaraderie as you enjoy the fun, communal-style dining. It's a great spot if you're looking to indulge in lobster in a laid-back setting.

In a town known for seafood, Outer Banks Boil Company stands out as a top-notch choice. So, if you find yourself in St Augustine craving lobster, this is the place to be. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

St. Augustine Fish House & Oyster Company

During my visit to St. Augustine Fish House & Oyster Company, I was thrilled to indulge in their succulent lobster tail, which was flawlessly grilled and bursting with flavor. The tenderness of the meat was elevated by a touch of garlic butter, making each bite a delightful experience. The casual coastal atmosphere paired perfectly with the friendly service, ensuring I felt right at home. I also appreciated their extensive seafood menu, showcasing the best of what St. Augustine has to offer. If you’re in search of a lobster experience that dances on the palate, this charming spot is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

DJ's Clam Shack St. Augustine

At DJ's Clam Shack, I dove into their rock lobster rolls, which were a delightful surprise! The succulent lobster was generously loaded into a toasted bun, topped with a zesty aioli that danced on my taste buds. The casual, beachy vibe made the experience even more enjoyable, as I savored each bite under the warm Florida sun. Their lobster was perfectly cooked—tender yet firm, showcasing the ocean's freshness. Overall, this spot is a must-visit for lobster lovers looking for a fun and flavorful experience in St Augustine! 🦞

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille

At Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille, I savored their lobster étouffée, a delightful combination of tender lobster and spicy, rich sauce served over a bed of fluffy rice. The blend of flavors danced on my palate, making it a memorable dish that perfectly blends Southern charm with coastal flair. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with attentive service, made my dining experience even more enjoyable. If you’re seeking a lobster adventure in St Augustine, Harry's is a must-visit. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and classic recipes truly sets the stage for an unforgettable meal!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Salt Life Food Shack

Salt Life Food Shack in St Augustine is a delightful gem where the coastal vibe meets delicious culinary creativity. The lobster tacos I savored were a highlight, brimming with fresh flavors and topped with a zesty sauce that tantalized my taste buds. Each bite felt like a mini vacation! The atmosphere is as vibrant as the dishes, making it a perfect spot for both locals and tourists. If you’re looking for a laid-back dining experience with delicious lobster options, this place certainly delivers. Don't miss the chance to indulge; it’s an experience that’s as refreshing as the sea breeze!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Lobstah On A Roll - St. Augustine, Florida

From the moment I stepped into Lobstah On A Roll, I was greeted by a delightful coastal vibe. Their lobster rolls are a true culinary masterpiece, featuring tender, fresh lobster drizzled with butter and lemon—simply irresistible! The soft, toasted roll cradled the succulent lobster perfectly, making every bite a celebration of flavor. I particularly loved their unique twist with spicy mayo, adding an unexpected kick. The casual atmosphere and friendly staff made it enjoyable to indulge in this lobster delight. Overall, if you’re seeking an unforgettable lobster experience, look no further than Lobstah On A Roll!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

The Conch House Restaurant

Nestled on the waterfront, The Conch House Restaurant is a delightful treasure. I indulged in their succulent lobster tail, grilled to perfection and served with a tantalizing garlic butter sauce that had me swooning. The ambiance is as vibrant as the flavors, making you feel like you're on a tropical escape. I must say, the blend of spices elevates the dish, transforming each bite into a mini celebration of maritime goodness. If you’re searching for a fantastic lobster experience, this spot deserves a top-tier mention on your culinary journey through St Augustine. Don't forget to pair it with their tropical cocktails!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

The Boathouse St. Augustine

During my visit to The Boathouse St. Augustine, I was immediately enchanted by the waterfront views and the lively atmosphere. Their lobster tail was a true revelation—perfectly grilled and brushed with a garlic herb butter that delighted the senses. Each succulent bite was an explosion of flavor, accompanied by a refreshing lobster bisque that was rich yet not overpowering. The staff provided impeccable service, further elevating the experience. If you’re seeking an unforgettable lobster dish in a charming setting, The Boathouse truly delivers on all fronts—making it a must-visit for seafood lovers. 🌊🦞

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.