![St Augustine's Best Paella [Updated 2025]](/images/posts/p/paella-st-augustine.webp)
After devouring countless plates of this Spanish delight, I’ve meticulously reviewed twelve of the top spots in town to find the absolute best paella. Trust me, my taste buds have been on quite the adventure!
With a passion for food that runs as deep as my love for this historic city, I’ve gathered insights from locals and chefs alike, ensuring that you get the scoop on where to find that perfect blend of saffron, seafood, and spices. Whether you're a paella aficionado or just curious about this culinary treasure, I promise you’re in for a flavorful ride that’s worth every bite!
Casa Maya
☎️ 904-823-0787
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Exceptional customer service |
| Great food and atmosphere |
| Live music entertainment |
| Generous portion sizes |
| Delicious bar drinks |
Casa Maya in St Augustine is a delightful gem that stole my heart with its vibrant ambiance and tantalizing paella. From the moment I stepped through the door, I was welcomed with exceptional customer service that set the tone for an unforgettable evening. The cheerful staff made me feel right at home, which is essential in a restaurant experience.
What truly stood out was the generous portion sizes of the paella. Bursting with fresh seafood and succulent chicken, each bite revealed a delightful harmony of flavors that danced on my palate. The saffron-infused rice was prepared to perfection, achieving that perfect balance between tenderness and a hint of crispiness at the bottom—a true hallmark of a great paella.
As I savored my meal, I was delighted by the live music entertainment that added to the lively atmosphere, making it a feast not just for the taste buds but for the senses. Whether pairing my dish with one of their delicious bar drinks or enjoying the casual chatter, it was an experience to remember. In my quest for the best paella in St Augustine, Casa Maya stands out as a joyous culinary celebration that I can't wait to revisit!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.
Cap's On the Water
☎️ 904-824-8794
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Stunning sunset views |
| Friendly and efficient service |
| Casual atmosphere |
| Diverse seafood offerings |
| Spacious outdoor seating |
Review of Cap's On the Water
Nestled on the picturesque banks of the intracoastal, Cap's On the Water is a delightful oasis for seafood lovers. As I settled into the casual atmosphere, I was immediately captivated by the stunning sunset views, making it the perfect backdrop for my culinary adventure.
When the paella arrived, I couldn't help but admire the colorful presentation, which signaled the freshness of the ingredients. This dish brilliantly showcased a diverse array of seafood, from plump shrimp to succulent mussels, all expertly harmonized in a perfect medley of flavors. The rice was cooked to perfection, absorbing the rich, aromatic broth without losing its ideal texture.
What truly enhanced my experience was the friendly and efficient service; the staff was attentive yet unobtrusive, ensuring that my dining experience flowed seamlessly. With spacious outdoor seating, I felt enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that complimented the delicious fare.
In the realm of paellas and seafood, Cap's is undoubtedly deserving of a visit. If you're looking for a delightful evening filled with vibrant flavors and breathtaking vistas, this place is a must!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville.
Catch 27
☎️ 904-650-7808
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Elevated dining experience |
| Craft cocktails are exceptional |
| Beautiful outdoor dining area |
| Peaceful and intimate atmosphere |
| Small, focused menu |
Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Catch 27 offers a delightful culinary experience that takes the classic paella to innovative heights. As I settled into their charming outdoor dining area, I couldn't help but admire the peaceful ambiance, perfect for an evening of indulgence.
The small, focused menu at Catch 27 is a testament to their commitment to quality. Their paella, vibrant with colors, was a feast for both the eyes and palate. Each bite revealed a harmonious blend of fresh seafood, succulent chicken, and perfectly cooked rice, capturing the essence of traditional Spanish flavors while highlighting local ingredients.
Pairing my paella with one of their craft cocktails—a refreshing touch—elevated the entire experience. The mixologist's attention to detail mirrored the chef’s dedication in the kitchen.
The overall atmosphere was intimate and inviting, making it the ideal setting for a memorable meal. If you’re strolling through St. Augustine and craving a delicious paella, Catch 27 is a must-visit—a captivating culinary gem that leaves you wanting more!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine Beach.
Taberna del Caballo
☎️ 904-342-2867
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Phenomenal service |
| Delicious short rib |
| Amazing datil hot sauce |
| Dog friendly outdoor seating |
| Tasty plantains and beans |
Taberna del Caballo offers a delightful twist on traditional Spanish cuisine, and their paella is an absolute symphony of flavors. As I settled into the cozy atmosphere, I was greeted by phenomenal service that made me feel right at home. The staff was attentive and incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, which always enhances the dining experience.
The star of the show, the paella, arrived with a vibrant array of colors and aromas. What truly captivated my taste buds was the heavenly combination of saffron-infused rice, succulent seafood, and tender meat. The stunning inclusion of short rib added a rich, savory depth that I hadn't anticipated.
I couldn't resist pairing my dish with the amazing datil hot sauce. It lent a gentle kick that enlivened every bite, enhancing rather than overpowering the delicate flavors of the paella. The dog-friendly outdoor seating created a charming environment, especially as I enjoyed my meal surrounded by the gentle St. Augustine breeze.
To top it all off, the side of tasty plantains and beans complemented my selection beautifully. If you're hunting for the best paella experience in St Augustine, look no further than Taberna del Caballo. This place knows how to bring unforgettable flavors to the table!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.
Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar
☎️ 904-827-1888
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Outstanding food quality |
| Exceptional service experience |
| Inviting and friendly atmosphere |
| Delicious craft cocktails |
| Memorable dessert options |
At Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar, my culinary adventure took a delightful turn with their exceptional paella. Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, this gem welcomes guests with a warm, inviting atmosphere that immediately captures the essence of coastal dining. The food quality is outstanding—each grain of rice perfectly cooked and infused with a myriad of flavors that transport you straight to Spain.
The combination of tender seafood, succulent meats, and a vibrant array of vegetables is nothing short of mesmerizing. What impressed me most was the balance of spices, weaving a tapestry of taste that sang on my palate. Paired with one of their craft cocktails, each sip enhanced my dining experience, making it feel truly special.
Moreover, the service experience deserves a special mention; the staff was attentive yet unobtrusive, ensuring that my meal was nothing less than remarkable. And let's not forget the memorable dessert options that rounded out my meal beautifully, making me want to return for more.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in St. Augustine, treat yourself to the playing symphony of flavors that is the paella at Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar—a culinary delight you won't soon forget!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.
River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge
☎️ 904-481-8396
🌐 Website
| Highlights |
|---|
| Incredible Date Night Spot |
| Stunning Bay View Dining |
| Great Atmosphere and Energy |
| Delicious Cocktails Offered |
| Friendly and Attentive Service |
Review of River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge
Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, River & Fort is a gem that caught my culinary eye during my quest for the ultimate paella. From the moment I stepped inside, I was captivated by the incredible atmosphere that perfectly blends historic charm with modern flair. With a stunning view of the bay, this spot is ideal not just for a delightful meal, but also for an enchanting date night.
When it came to the paella, I was greeted by a vibrant dish brimming with fresh seafood and tender chicken, all harmoniously mingled with saffron-infused rice. Each bite burst with flavor—it's easy to see why locals rave about it! The attentive staff ensured that my glass was never empty, making every moment even more enjoyable.
As the sun began to set, the transformed energy of the rooftop lounge enticed me to sip on their craft cocktails while basking in the scenic views. If you’re searching for paella that waltzes off the plate and dances into the heart, River & Fort should definitely be at the top of your list. It’s a delightful feast for both the eyes and the palate!
You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Ponte Vedra.
Columbia Restaurant
☎️ 904-824-3341
🌐 Website
With its vibrant ambiance and rich history, Columbia Restaurant offers an unforgettable paella experience. I was instantly drawn to the sizzling textures and alluring aromas wafting from the kitchen. Their traditional seafood paella is a symphony of flavors, boasting succulent shrimp, tender mussels, and perfectly cooked rice infused with saffron. Each bite transports you to the sun-soaked coasts of Spain. The generous portion and delightful presentation make it a standout. Coupled with a refreshing sangria, Columbia has truly perfected the art of paella. If you seek a culinary escape, this gem in St Augustine is not to be missed!
You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.
Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille
☎️ 904-824-7765
🌐 Website
At Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille, the paella is a vibrant celebration of flavors! The saffron-infused rice is perfectly cooked, acting as a delightful canvas for succulent shrimp, tender calamari, and juicy mussels. I was particularly impressed by the generous portions, making it a feast worth savoring. The atmosphere is lively, complemented by friendly service that adds to the experience. While they offer a range of dishes, this paella is a standout; it’s a must-try for any seafood lover visiting St Augustine. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in this delightful dish!
You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.
De Leon Latin Cocina
☎️ 904-827-4081
At De Leon Latin Cocina, the paella was an absolute delight! Each vibrant bite of saffron-infused rice danced on my palate, perfectly complemented by a medley of fresh seafood and tender chicken. The aroma alone had me dreaming of sun-soaked shores. The generous portions invite you to savor every morsel while enjoying the lively atmosphere. Service was attentive, yet relaxed, making the visit all the more enjoyable. If you're on a quest for the ultimate paella experience in St Augustine, this gem should not be missed — it’s a fiesta on your plate!
You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.
Llama Restaurant
☎️ 904-819-1760
🌐 Website
At Llama Restaurant, the paella is a delightful fusion of flavors that dances on your palate. The seafood delight—bursting with plump shrimp, mussels, and tender calamari—pairs beautifully with saffron-infused rice, cooked to perfection. Each bite offers a warm embrace of spices with just the right amount of heat. The ambiance is lively, making it an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and festive gatherings. Don’t skip the sangria; it’s the perfect companion to this culinary adventure. If you're hunting for standout paella in St Augustine, Llama is a must-visit gem that will leave you craving more!
You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.
Cortesse's Bistro and Flamingo Room Piano Bar
☎️ 904-694-5892
🌐 Website
During my visit to Cortesse's Bistro and Flamingo Room Piano Bar, I was transported straight to Spain with their delightful paella. The dish was a vibrant medley of saffron-infused rice, tender seafood, and perfectly cooked chicken, each bite a symphony of flavors. The atmosphere, enhanced by live piano music, set the stage for a memorable dining experience. The generous portion size left me both satisfied and nostalgic for sun-soaked Spanish shores. If you’re searching for a playful yet refined culinary adventure, this paella is not to be missed! Don't skip the dessert—the perfect ending to a fantastic meal!
You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.
Collage
☎️ 904-829-0055
🌐 Website
Tucked away in the heart of St. Augustine, Collage offers a paella that dances on the palate. Each bite bursts with fresh seafood and tender chicken, while a symphony of saffron and spices creates a rich canvas. The presentation is nothing short of artful, making it almost too beautiful to eat—almost! The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy evening. Collage has mastered the balance of flavors; it’s a dish that speaks to both tradition and creativity. For anyone seeking a delightful culinary escape, this paella is not just a meal; it’s an experience to savor.
You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.
