St Augustine's Best Oysters [Updated 2025]

After countless tastings and unforgettable evenings spent savoring these briny delights, I’ve handpicked 12 top-notch spots that truly showcase what the ancient city has to offer. Each location has its own unique vibe and twist on oysters, whether you’re a fan of classic preparations or adventurous flavor combinations.

As someone who’s spent years exploring St Augustine’s culinary wonders, I promise you this isn’t just another list—it's a heartfelt dive into the best places to indulge in these ocean gems. So grab a fork, get ready to slurp, and let’s uncover the hidden treasures that await right here in our beautiful city!

Cap's On the Water

Highlights
Beautiful sunset views
Casual, friendly atmosphere
Excellent service experience
Delicious variety of oysters
Spacious outdoor seating

Cap's On the Water is a true gem for oyster enthusiasts seeking both flavor and ambiance. Nestled along the serene waterways of St Augustine, this restaurant offers not just a meal but a delightful experience. As I settled into my seat, I was immediately captivated by the stunning sunset views that paint the sky in soft hues—a perfect backdrop to complement my oyster feast.

The atmosphere is wonderfully casual and welcoming, making one feel right at home. The staff provided excellent service with a genuine smile, ensuring I had everything I needed to enjoy my culinary adventure. And oh, the oysters! They come in a delicious variety, ranging from briny to sweet, each one fresher than the last. Whether you enjoy them raw, grilled, or baked, Cap's has got you covered.

Seated outdoors in the spacious area, I was able to savor these treasures while soaking in the fresh air and picturesque views. Each oyster was a delightful morsel, truly a little piece of heaven! If you find yourself in St Augustine, do yourself a favor and visit Cap's On the Water. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

Aunt Kates

Highlights
Friendly atmosphere
Incredible waterfront views
Delicious food options
Dog-friendly patio
Excellent service

At Aunt Kates, I was captivated by the vibrant friendly atmosphere that enveloped me as I stepped onto the dog-friendly patio. The incredible waterfront views are nothing short of breathtaking, with the shimmering waters of the Matanzas River enhancing my dining experience. As I settled into my seat, I couldn’t resist diving into a plate of their renowned oysters, which were impressively fresh and delectable.

These briny beauties, served on the half shell, showcased a delightful balance of salty and sweet flavors that danced on my palate. The excellent service from the attentive staff made the experience even more enjoyable, as they were eager to share their recommendations and ensure I had everything I needed for an unforgettable meal.

Pairing the oysters with a crisp glass of white wine elevated the experience to new heights, making it a perfect afternoon retreat. Between the delicious food options and the scenic backdrop, Aunt Kates is undoubtedly a must-visit for anyone seeking the best oysters in St Augustine. Whether you're a local or a tourist, this spot is sure to cast a spell on your taste buds and leave you longing for another visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville.

St. Augustine Seafood Company

Highlights
Confusing ordering process
Flavorful but cold food
Tasty shrimp tacos
Good for a quick bite
In the historic area

St. Augustine Seafood Company has carved out a niche for itself amidst the historic charm of St. Augustine, attracting both locals and visitors alike. Upon entering, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere, though the ordering process was a bit confusing for a newcomer. Nevertheless, I decided to dive into their oysters.

When the platter arrived, I was ready to indulge, but I must admit, the oysters were a tad on the cold side, lacking the fresh, briny warmth one typically craves. Still, the flavor was commendable, a delicate balance of sweetness and saltiness. I couldn’t resist pairing my oyster adventure with their unexpected delight: the shrimp tacos. These were so flavorful, bursting with texture and zest!

While it may not be the top destination for a gourmet oyster experience, St. Augustine Seafood Company is undeniably a perfect stop for a quick bite after wandering the historic district. Its location makes it easy to pop in, and the casual vibe offers a relaxed dining experience. I left feeling satisfied, though eager for a warmer batch of oysters on my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine Beach.

River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge

Highlights
Incredible date night venue
Great atmosphere and energy
Beautiful bay views
Delicious appetizers recommended
Attentive and welcoming service

River & Fort Restaurant & Roof Top Lounge is a charming destination that utterly exceeded my expectations during my quest for the best oysters in St Augustine. Nestled along the waterfront, this venue boasts breathtaking bay views that perfectly set the stage for an unforgettable evening. The atmosphere is alive with an energetic buzz, making it an ideal spot for a romantic date night or a fun gathering with friends.

Upon my arrival, I was greeted by the attentive and welcoming service, which made me feel right at home. I started my culinary adventure with their oysters, which were as fresh as the sea breeze wafting through the air. Each bite was a delightful experience, showcasing the briny essence of the ocean, complemented by a zesty mignonette that enhanced the flavor without overwhelming it.

In addition to the oysters, I was tempted by their selection of appetizers, which did not disappoint. However, the real star of the show was when I savored those delectable oysters—simply divine! Looking back, River & Fort has solidified itself as one of my favorite spots for oysters in this historic city, and I can't wait to return for another tasting adventure!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

St. Augustine Fish House & Oyster Company

St. Augustine Fish House & Oyster Company delights the senses as soon as you step through the door. With an atmosphere that captures the coastal charm of Florida, it's the perfect spot for oyster lovers. I savored their briny gems, which are served fresh and with a touch of zest that dances on the palate. The variety offered, from classic raw to grilled options with delightful toppings, had me in oyster heaven! Friendly staff and a lively ambiance made the experience even more enjoyable. If you’re seeking the ultimate oyster indulgence in St. Augustine, this place deserves a top spot on your list!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille

At Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille, the oysters are nothing short of a culinary delight! These succulent gems are served fresh from local waters, offering a briny taste that dances on your palate. I adored their Oysters Rockefeller, which feature a perfect blend of rich toppings that elevate the experience to pure indulgence. The lively atmosphere, infused with the spirit of the South, makes every slurp a joyful occasion. Pair your oysters with a zesty cocktail, and you're in for a treat. If you're in St Augustine, don’t miss this gem—it's an inviting spot for both oyster aficionados and newcomers alike!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Ponte Vedra.

Catch 27

During my recent visit to Catch 27, I was ready to dive into a briny adventure. Their locally sourced oysters were a revelation—plump and bursting with flavor. Each bite was a delightful harmony of saltiness and sweetness. Served with a zesty mignonette that provided a perfect punch, these oysters are a must-try. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff added to the experience, making it both inviting and enjoyable. If you're hunting for the ultimate oyster feast in St Augustine, look no further than Catch 27—it’s a treasure trove of the ocean’s best! 🦪🌊

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

O'Steen's Restaurant

My recent visit to O'Steen's Restaurant was nothing short of spectacular. Nestled in the heart of St Augustine, this charming eatery serves up some of the best oysters I've tasted. The flavorful, perfectly shucked beauties were a delightful combination of freshness and brine, served with a zesty cocktail sauce that truly elevated the experience. Each bite was a symphony of oceanic bliss. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly service made my oyster adventure even more enjoyable. If you find yourself in St Augustine, don't miss out on the oyster perfection here at O'Steen's—it’s a culinary treasure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Salt Life Food Shack

At Salt Life Food Shack, I dove into a delightful selection of oysters that truly impressed. The freshness was sensational, each briny bite transporting me straight to the coast. Pairing them with their zesty house-made mignonette added an exciting twist. The vibrant, beachy atmosphere made it the perfect spot to savor these treasures. Plus, the friendly staff provided exceptional service, enhancing my overall experience. If you’re seeking an oyster adventure in St Augustine, Salt Life should definitely be on your radar. It's a place where flavor meets fun—definitely a must-visit for any seafood lover!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Schooner's Seafood House

Nestled by the shimmering waters, Schooner's Seafood House is a delightful treasure for oyster lovers. Their raw oysters, served on ice with a zesty mignonette, burst with briny flavor that transports you straight to the ocean. I found the charbroiled variety equally irresistible, smothered in a savory garlic butter blend. The laid-back atmosphere enhances the experience, making it perfect for a casual outing. Each bite at Schooner's reveals the essence of the sea—fresh, flavorful, and simply unforgettable. If you’re in search of a shellfish escape, this gem is a must-visit. Cheers to a delightful oyster adventure!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Meehan's Irish Pub & Seafood House

At Meehan's Irish Pub & Seafood House, I found myself in oyster paradise. Their freshly shucked oysters were a delightful treat, with a briny flavor that danced on the palate. Served on a bed of ice, each oyster was plump and bursting with the taste of the sea. The whimsical atmosphere added to the experience, making it a perfect spot to savor these gems. Don’t miss their zesty mignonette sauce, which elevated the oysters to another level. Overall, my visit was a joyous culinary adventure that left me craving more!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Kingfish Grill On the Water

At Kingfish Grill On the Water, the oysters were a delightful surprise—plump and briny, they practically danced on my palate! Served fresh on the half shell, each bite delivered a sweet ocean breeze, enhanced by a tangy cocktail sauce that had just the right kick. The scenic waterfront view made the experience even more enchanting, with the sun setting behind the rippling waves. The casual yet inviting atmosphere paired perfectly with the expertly crafted seafood dishes. If you're in search of oyster perfection, this gem is a must-visit. Come for the oysters, stay for the view!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.