St Augustine's Best Dessert [Updated 2025]

As I wandered through the cobblestone streets, each charming shop and café whispered secrets of their sweet creations. After indulging my sweet tooth at 12 top dessert spots, I can confidently say that St. Augustine is a treasure trove for dessert lovers. Whether you're craving a classic slice of cake or a unique twist on a traditional treat, I've tasted it all and am here to share the gems that truly stand out.

You can trust my perspective because I’ve tasted the good, the bad, and the downright delicious. So, grab your fork and prepare for a mouthwatering journey through my favorite sweet spots in this historic city. Your next favorite dessert is just a bite away!

Castillo Ice Cream and coffee

Highlights
Fabulous Service
Varied Ice Cream Selection
Affogato with Coffee Ice Cream
Great for All Weather
Pleasant Atmosphere

As I strolled through the charming streets of St. Augustine, I stumbled upon Castillo Ice Cream and Coffee, a delightful haven for dessert lovers. Right from the start, the fabulous service captured my attention. The staff was not just friendly; they were genuinely enthusiastic about sharing their recommendations!

The varied ice cream selection had my taste buds tingling with excitement. However, the standout for me was the affogato served with a scoop of rich, creamy coffee ice cream. Imagine a perfect balance between intense coffee flavor and the sweet, velvety texture that makes your heart sing with joy. It was an experience that danced on my palate and left me wanting more.

Although the weather in St. Augustine can be unpredictable, Castillo’s charming atmosphere created the perfect setting to indulge in this delicious treat. With warm hues and inviting decor, I found myself wanting to linger just a little longer.

If you’re searching for the best dessert in St. Augustine, I wholeheartedly recommend making a stop at Castillo. You won't be disappointed by the tantalizing selection and heartfelt service that await you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

Une Autre Histoire, La French Bakery (Les Petits Pleasures)

Highlights
Cozy atmosphere
Authentic French pastries
Fresh and delicious treats
Decadent, moist desserts
Eco-friendly coffee cups

Une Autre Histoire, La French Bakery (Les Petits Pleasures) is an absolute gem tucked away in the heart of St Augustine! As soon as I stepped inside, the cozy atmosphere enveloped me, inviting me to linger longer than planned. The air was filled with the unmistakable aroma of authentic French pastries, and I could already feel my dessert dreams coming to life.

I decided to treat myself to one of their signature éclairs, and let me tell you, it was a slice of heaven! Each bite revealed decadent, moist layers that effortlessly combined flavors. The pastry cream was rich yet airy, making it an experience rather than just a sweet fix. My coffee, served in eco-friendly cups, paired perfectly with the treat, allowing me to savor the moment guilt-free.

The friendly staff added to the charm, making my visit feel like a warm embrace. If you're looking for fresh and delicious treats that transport you to a quaint Parisian bakery, Une Autre Histoire should absolutely be at the top of your list. This dessert haven is not just a stop; it’s a delightful destination!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville.

Peace Pie

Highlights
Unique ice cream sandwiches
Conveniently wrapped for travel
Hidden gem in downtown
Indulgent flavors like salted caramel and chocolate
Perfect for a stroll in the historic district

When I stumbled upon Peace Pie in downtown St Augustine, I realized I had found a hidden gem. The playful concept of unique ice cream sandwiches truly caught my eye. The delicious creations, made with two scrumptious cookies and a layer of delightful ice cream in between, were simply irresistible!

I opted for the salted caramel and chocolate flavor combo—every bit as indulgent as it sounds. Each bite was a heavenly blend of textures and tastes, from the rich ice cream to the melt-in-your-mouth cookies. What’s more, they’re cleverly wrapped, making them perfect for savoring on a stroll through the historic district.

The whimsical atmosphere of the shop only added to the experience, emanating a warmth that complemented the sweet treats. It’s a fantastic place to satisfy your dessert cravings, whether you’re a local or just visiting. In a town filled with unforgettable charm, Peace Pie stands out as a must-try dessert stop—packed with flavors that leave you craving just one more bite! If you're on the hunt for the best dessert in St Augustine, this spot definitely deserves a visit.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine Beach.

Whetstone Chocolates

Highlights
Proverbial Mecca for Chocolate
Decadent Gift Options
Top-Notch Chocolate
Attentive Customer Service
Delicious Ice Cream Flavors

Whetstone Chocolates is nothing short of a proverbial mecca for chocolate lovers! The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by the irresistible aroma of rich, high-quality chocolate that envelops you like a warm hug. As I strolled through the aisles adorned with their beautifully crafted confections, I felt as if I was in a sugar-laden paradise.

Their selection of chocolate is not just top-notch; it’s a delightful melange of classic and innovative flavors that keep you coming back for more. The handcrafted truffles were my personal favorite—each bite is a stunning revelation of flavor and texture. But let’s not overlook their delicious ice cream, which is an equally mesmerizing treat!

What truly set my experience apart was the attentive customer service. The staff was eager to share their knowledge and passion for the craft of chocolate-making, which only intensified my appreciation for their delectable offerings.

Whether you're looking for the perfect gift option or just a sweet indulgence for yourself, Whetstone Chocolates lives up to its reputation. If you find yourself in St Augustine, this should be at the top of your dessert itinerary.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Tedi's Olde Tyme Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique ice cream flavors
Friendly and polite staff
Great variety of options
Popular local favorite
Charming atmosphere

Tedi's Olde Tyme Ice Cream is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of St Augustine that stole my sweet tooth’s affections! As soon as I walked in, the charming atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug, inviting me to sample their unique assortment of ice cream flavors. From classic vanilla to adventurous lavender honey, Tedi’s offers an array that makes it tough to choose just one.

The staff was an absolute pleasure, with their friendly smiles and polite service, enhancing the overall experience. I went for a scoop of their caramel sea salt, which delivered a deliciously decadent balance of sweetness and a touch of savory saltiness—truly divine!

It’s clear this place has cemented itself as a popular local favorite. It was bustling with families and friends enjoying the simple joy of ice cream, creating a lively energy that felt infectious. Each bite not only satisfied my dessert craving but also made me feel a part of the St Augustine community.

If you’re in search of the best dessert experience in this historic city, don’t miss Tedi's Olde Tyme Ice Cream—where every scoop feels like a celebration!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

The Sweet Spot

Stepping into The Sweet Spot feels like entering a whimsical dessert wonderland! I was immediately greeted by the scent of freshly baked goodies and the sight of colorful confections. I indulged in their signature key lime pie brownies, which perfectly combined the tartness of key lime with rich, fudgy chocolate. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors, making it a true must-try. The atmosphere is charming, with cheerful staff eager to make your dessert dreams come true. If you find yourself in St Augustine, don’t miss this sugary haven; it's a delightful escape for any dessert lover!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Ponte Vedra.

Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar

At Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar, each sip and bite feels like a whimsical adventure! The decadent milkshakes are topped with everything from whipped cream to donuts, creating a feast for the eyes before the taste buds rejoice. I opted for the salted caramel waffle, which was light yet indulgent, perfectly paired with a rich, creamy shake. The vibrant atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a delightful spot for dessert enthusiasts. If you’re seeking a playful twist on classic delights, this gem is a must-visit in St Augustine—your sweet tooth will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

The St. Augustine Scoop

As I stepped into The St. Augustine Scoop, the intoxicating aroma of freshly made waffle cones greeted me like an old friend. This delightful ice cream parlor boasts a vast array of flavors, each more enticing than the last. I opted for the Key Lime Pie ice cream, and oh, what a revelation! The balance of tangy lime and creamy sweetness danced on my palate. Topped with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of graham cracker crumble, it was a heavenly indulgence. If you find yourself in St. Augustine, this charming spot is a must-visit for dessert lovers! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Crème de la Cocoa

Walking into Crème de la Cocoa felt like stepping into a whimsical dessert wonderland! Their decadent chocolate truffles were a delightful surprise, each bite bursting with rich flavors that danced on my palate. I savored the lavender-infused cake, which offered a delicate balance of floral notes and sweetness that was simply enchanting.

The atmosphere was cozy yet vibrant, making it the perfect spot for indulging in heavenly treats. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this charming shop is a must-visit for dessert lovers. Crème de la Cocoa truly captures the spirit of St Augustine’s dessert scene!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Mayday Ice Cream is a whimsical delight for both young and old. Their handcrafted flavors are nothing short of magical! I indulged in a scoop of the Salted Caramel Pretzel, where the sweet and salty dance brilliantly on your palate. The fresh, creamy texture seemed to melt away all worries, leaving behind a blissful smile. The quirky decor adds to the charm, making it the perfect stop after a day of exploring. If you’re searching for the best dessert in St. Augustine, Mayday’s ice cream is undoubtedly a treat you shouldn’t miss!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Mayday Ice Cream St. Augustine Beach

Mayday Ice Cream at St. Augustine Beach is a delightful scoop of joy! With a whimsical atmosphere, this charming shop serves up a kaleidoscope of bold flavors and textures that playfully dance on your palate. I couldn't resist trying the Salted Caramel Pretzel, which beautifully combines sweet and salty notes in every bite. The creamy, artisanal base is undeniably refreshing, making it the perfect treat after a sun-soaked day at the beach. Each lick transported me to dessert heaven! If you’re searching for a unique ice cream experience, Mayday is an absolute must-visit for any dessert lover!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company

Upon stepping into Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company, I was immediately enveloped in a symphony of sweet aromas. Their cheesecake, a decadent triumph, features a creamy texture that dances on the palate, perfectly complemented by a buttery graham cracker crust. I tried the key lime cheesecake, which had just the right tang—refreshing yet indulgent. The friendly staff added a personal touch to my visit, making the experience all the more delightful. For anyone seeking a little slice of heaven, this quaint spot is a must-visit in St Augustine. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.