St Augustine Historic District's Best Pizza [Updated 2025]

There’s something magical about the way a slice of pizza can bring people together, especially in a place as vibrant as St. Augustine. After sampling crusts, sauces, and toppings at twelve of the top pizzerias in our charming Historic District, I’m here to share the delicious discoveries I’ve made.

Trust me, I’ve navigated those narrow, cobblestone streets in search of the perfect pie, and each stop has a story. Whether you’re a resident looking for a new favorite or a visitor craving a slice of local flavor, my insights will help you find your next pizza obsession—because when it comes to pizza, I believe every slice should be an adventure!

Saint Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Elegant waterfront dining
Beautiful courtyard ambiance
Impeccable and warm service
Must-try bread selection
Modern Italian gem

At Saint Italian Restaurant, the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a cozy yet elegant ambiance that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Nestled against a picturesque waterfront, the delightful courtyard beckons diners to enjoy their meals under the sun or stars, enhancing the overall atmosphere.

Now, onto the star of the show—the pizza! I savored their classic Margherita, which boasted a perfect crust that was both thin and crispy, yet chewy. The premium mozzarella and vibrant basil made each bite a celebration of freshness. It was clearly crafted with dedication and expertise.

But what truly set this place apart was the impeccable service. The staff was warm and knowledgeable, eager to share their recommendations, and they treated every patron like family.

To start, don’t overlook their must-try bread selection; it was the perfect companion to my meal. In short, Saint Italian Restaurant stands out as a modern Italian gem, blending delightful cuisine with a charming atmosphere. If you find yourself in the St Augustine Historic District, this spot is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

At Pizzalley's Chianti Room, I was greeted by a delightful ambiance that perfectly complements their mouthwatering pizza. I indulged in their signature pie, which boasted a thin, crispy crust topped with fresh mozzarella and vibrant basil. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, and the rich tomato sauce had just the right kick of zest. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring a delightful dining experience. For anyone wandering the historic streets craving a slice of pizza heaven, Pizzalley's will not disappoint! If you find yourself in the Historic District, this gem is a must-visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Carmelo's Pizzeria

When I strolled into Carmelo's Pizzeria, the aroma of fresh-baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. Their Margherita pizza was a delightful symphony of flavors, with the vibrant basil dancing atop the rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella. Each bite was a testament to authenticity, showcasing the craftsmanship that makes this spot a local favorite. The cozy atmosphere, dotted with charming decor, invites you to linger longer. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a slice to go, Carmelo's is a must-visit for pizza lovers exploring the Historic District. Don’t miss their gelato—a sweet ending to a perfect meal!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Pizzalley's on St. George

At Pizzalley's on St. George, I found myself in a delightful pizza paradise! The crust, perfectly crisped to golden perfection, cradled a symphony of fresh toppings. I opted for their signature Margherita, and the sweet basil paired beautifully with the rich tomato sauce and melted mozzarella. The atmosphere buzzed with lively chatter, enhancing the overall experience. Best of all, the friendly staff made me feel right at home. For anyone seeking a pizza adventure in the Historic District, Pizzalley's is a must-try! 🍕✨ Deliciousness awaits!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Bronx House Pizza - St. Augustine

Stepping into Bronx House Pizza - St. Augustine felt like a delightful trip to New York! Their classic thin crust pizza is an absolute masterpiece, perfectly crispy with a heavenly blend of fresh mozzarella and zesty tomato sauce. I indulged in the pepperoni delight, where each slice was bursting with flavor and a satisfying crunch. The cozy atmosphere added to the charm, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a slice. If you’re in the Historic District, don’t miss this gem—it’s a slice of pizza paradise that will leave your taste buds dancing! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

Piesanos St Augustine

At Piesanos St Augustine, I was greeted by a warm Italian ambiance that perfectly complements their delicious offerings. The thin, crispy crust was a delightful revelation, and the classic Margherita pizza stole the show with its fresh basil and tangy tomato sauce. Each bite was a burst of flavor that danced on my palate. The staff were genuinely friendly, adding to the welcoming atmosphere. If you find yourself wandering the charming streets of the Historic District, don’t miss out on this gem! Piesanos truly knows how to serve up a slice of magic. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.

Nonnas Trattoria

Walking into Nonnas Trattoria felt like stepping into a cozy Italian kitchen, and I was immediately drawn to the ambiance. Their wood-fired pizzas are a true delight, showcasing a perfect balance of crispy crust and fresh toppings. I savored the classic Margherita, where the rich tomato sauce and melty mozzarella danced beautifully with fragrant basil. Each bite was a reminder of why simplicity can be sublime. The friendly service added to the charm, making me feel like part of the family. If you’re in the Historic District, don’t miss out on this gem—your taste buds will thank you! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Jacksonville.

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine transported me to a whimsical pizza paradise! The funky decor and vibrant atmosphere set the stage for an unforgettable culinary adventure. I indulged in the Holy Shiitake, and let me tell you—it was a fantastic fusion of flavors that tantalized my taste buds! The crust was perfectly crunchy yet wonderfully chewy, complementing the rich toppings brilliantly. The staff radiated warmth and enthusiasm, making the experience even more delightful. If you’re seeking a place that dishes out creative pizzas with a side of good vibes, Mellow Mushroom is a must-visit in the Historic District! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Ponte Vedra Beach.

Borrillo's Pizza and Beer & Wine Garden

Stepping into Borrillo's Pizza and Beer & Wine Garden felt like a warm embrace, with its vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff. I indulged in their classic Margherita pizza, and let me tell you—it was a slice of heaven! The crust was perfectly crispy, while the fresh basil and mozzarella danced harmoniously atop a robust tomato sauce. I can't forget to mention their diverse beer selection, which perfectly complemented my meal. If you're in search of a pizza that oozes authenticity and charm, then Borrillo's is an absolute must-visit! Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Jacksonville.

St. Augie's Pizza

St. Augie's Pizza is a delightful haven for pizza lovers! The moment I stepped in, the aroma of fresh ingredients and bubbling cheese embraced me. I opted for their signature St. Augie's Special, loaded with toppings galore. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors, with the crust—perfectly crispy yet chewy—stealing the show. The charming ambiance, paired with friendly service, made it an unforgettable experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this gem is a must-try. If you're wandering the historic district, don't miss out on this hotspot for unforgettable pizza bliss! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best brunch in St Augustine.

Pizza Time

Nestled in the heart of St Augustine's charming Historic District, Pizza Time is a delightful find that brings an irresistible blend of tradition and flavor. The moment I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering sauce whisked me away. I savored a classic pepperoni pizza, where the crust was perfectly crisp yet chewy, providing the ideal canvas for the zesty sauce and generous topping of small-batch mozzarella. Each bite danced on my palate, showcasing a delightful balance of tang and savory goodness. If you’re hunting for a slice of historic charm paired with delicious pizza, Pizza Time is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Jacksonville.

900º Pizza and Pasta

At 900º Pizza and Pasta, the moment I stepped in, the vibrant atmosphere enveloped me, sparking my appetite. Their artisan pizzas are crafted in a blazing hot oven that gives each pie a delightful char. I indulged in the Margherita—simple yet profoundly delicious, with fresh basil and creamy mozzarella that melted in harmony. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, making each bite a joy. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, adding to the overall experience. If you’re on the hunt for savory flavors and a cozy vibe, 900º is definitely a slice above the rest in St Augustine!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in St Augustine Historic District.