St Augustine's Best Ice Cream [Updated 2025]

There’s something magical about savoring a scoop of ice cream on a warm St. Augustine day, don’t you think? I’ve spent countless hours wandering the charming streets of this historic city, indulging in creamy delights from twelve of the top spots. Trust me, I’ve tasted everything from classic vanilla to mind-bending flavors you never knew existed.

With a palate honed by years of ice cream adventures, I’m here to help you navigate the sweetest side of St. Augustine. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, you’ll want to know where to find that perfect cone or cup that’ll make your taste buds dance. Let’s dive into this delicious journey together!

Twisted Turtle Creamery LLC

As soon as I stepped into Twisted Turtle Creamery LLC, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly made waffle cones. The variety of flavors here is truly astounding, from classic vanilla to whimsical combinations like turtle tracks and sea salt caramel. I opted for a scoop of their signature Turtle Surprise, a rich blend of chocolate, caramel, and pecans that danced on my palate. Each bite was a creamy delight, perfectly balanced and utterly indulgent. The charming atmosphere only enhanced my experience, marking this spot as a must-visit for anyone craving the best ice cream in St Augustine! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

The Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops

Highlights
Delicious unique flavors
Friendly and helpful staff
Tipsy pops available
Great for mid-day treat

When it comes to indulging in frozen treats, The Hyppo Gourmet Ice Pops takes the cake—or should I say popsicle! My visit to this vibrant establishment was nothing short of delightful. The moment I stepped in, I was welcomed by a delightful burst of colors and the friendly, helpful staff who were eager to assist in navigating their impressive menu of unique flavors.

What truly sets The Hyppo apart is its selection of deliciously unique flavors. From refreshing watermelon basil to the exotic mango chili, every bite is an adventure for your taste buds. I opted for the blackberry mint, which was a perfect balance of sweet and refreshing—ideal for a warm St Augustine day.

For the adventurous souls, tipsy pops are on offer, allowing guests to indulge in a grown-up twist on this classic treat. It's a delightful way to elevate your summer experience. My visit to The Hyppo was not only satisfying but also the perfect solution for a mid-day refreshment. If you find yourself in St Augustine, don’t miss the opportunity to relish the charm and creamy goodness that The Hyppo has to offer!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine

Tucked away in the heart of St. Augustine, Mayday Ice Cream is a delightful gem that tickled my taste buds! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by a charming retro vibe that set the tone for a whimsical ice cream adventure. I indulged in their S'mores flavor, a heavenly blend of chocolate, marshmallow, and graham cracker that transported me to a cozy campfire night. The creamy texture was pure bliss, and the generous portions left me feeling delightfully satisfied. If you're seeking artisanal ice cream with a playful twist, Mayday should be at the top of your list! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Mayday Ice Cream St. Augustine Beach

Mayday Ice Cream St. Augustine Beach is a delightful gem that captures the essence of summer with every scoop! Their creamy concoctions boast vibrant flavors, like the tantalizing sea salt caramel and the refreshing key lime pie. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for enjoying a treat by the beach. I was particularly enchanted by the whimsical decor and the friendly staff, who happily let me sample a few flavors. If you’re seeking a unique ice cream experience in St. Augustine, look no further—Mayday is a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists alike!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

The St. Augustine Scoop

Taking my taste buds on a delightful adventure, The St. Augustine Scoop truly stands out in the charming streets of St. Augustine. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with heavenly aromas and a vibrant atmosphere. I indulged in their salted caramel pretzel, a perfect harmony of sweet and salty that danced on my palate. Each scoop was generously proportioned, and the creamy texture was simply irresistible. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, adding to the joyful experience. If you're seeking a scoop of happiness, I highly recommend visiting this gem for the best ice cream in town! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

The Sweet Spot

The Sweet Spot in St Augustine is a delightful gem that truly lives up to its name! Upon entering, I was greeted by a whimsical atmosphere and an enticing array of flavors. I couldn't resist their salted caramel brownie, which was a perfect blend of creamy richness and a hint of indulgent sweetness. My companion chose the fresh mango sorbet, bursting with tropical flair. The friendly staff made the experience even sweeter, offering samples with a smile. If you’re on a quest for the finest ice cream in the area, The Sweet Spot is undoubtedly a must-visit! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.

Castillo Ice Cream and coffee

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Castillo Ice Cream and Coffee is a delightful haven for sweet tooths. I was immediately drawn in by the charming atmosphere and an aroma of freshly brewed coffee. Their homemade ice cream is a true star—each scoop bursting with flavor and crafted with care. I indulged in the Salted Caramel, which balanced sweet and savory to perfection. The staff were friendly and eager to offer samples, enhancing the experience. If you’re exploring the historic streets, don’t miss popping in for a frosty treat that will make your day a little brighter!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Jacksonville.

Cookiebird Ice Cream Bar

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Cookiebird Ice Cream Bar is a delightful gem that elevates simple indulgence to a whole new level. From the moment I stepped inside, the whimsical decor embraced me, setting the stage for a sweet adventure. I indulged in their signature cookie dough swirl, a heavenly blend with chunks of freshly baked cookies. Every bite was a perfect marriage of creamy and crunchy, offering a delightful contrast of textures. Not to mention, the friendly staff made my experience all the more enjoyable! If you're craving a treat that thrills, Cookiebird is a must-visit! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Ponte Vedra Beach.

Mayday Ice Cream Midtown St. Augustine

Stepping into Mayday Ice Cream Midtown felt like a whimsical journey into a world of flavors. Their unique handcrafted options are a delight, but the standout for me was the Salted Caramel Brownie—a luscious blend of sweet and salty that danced on my palate. The atmosphere is charming, with vibrant decor and friendly staff ready to guide you through their tempting selection. I also appreciated the dairy-free options, ensuring everyone can indulge. If you're in search of the best ice cream in St. Augustine, don't miss a scoop at Mayday—it’s a joyful experience you won’t soon forget!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Jacksonville.

Cold Cow

Stepping into Cold Cow felt like entering a whimsical dream where ice cream reigned supreme! Their eclectic menu boasts flavors that are both inventive and nostalgic. I indulged in the Sea Salt Caramel Brownie, which balanced sweet and salty in the most delightful way. Each bite was a creamy adventure that transported me back to carefree summers. The staff was friendly, adding to the welcoming atmosphere of this charming spot. If you're in St Augustine and looking for a scoop of happiness, Cold Cow is a must-visit! Don’t miss their rotating specials; they’re pure bliss!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in St Augustine.

Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar

Tucked away in the vibrant heart of St. Augustine, Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar is a delightful gem for ice cream lovers. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly made waffles enveloped me, promising an indulgent treat. Their signature ice cream, crafted from rich, creamy bases, took my taste buds on an unexpected adventure. I opted for the Salted Caramel Delight, perfectly balancing sweet and salty notes with an irresistible creamy texture. The ambiance is playful, adorned with charming nautical decor, making every visit feel like a mini-vacation. If you’re in town, don’t miss this fabulous spot!

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Jacksonville.

Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar A1A

Stepping into Cousteau's Waffle and Milkshake Bar A1A felt like entering a whimsical dessert paradise! Their decadent ice cream options are paired with mouth-watering waffles that perfectly complement every scoop. I indulged in their salted caramel sundae, which was rich and creamy, with just the right amount of salty sweetness. The waffle cone added an irresistible crunch that made each bite a delight! The charming atmosphere and friendly staff only enhanced my experience. If you're hunting for a playful twist on classic treats, Cousteau's is a must-visit in St Augustine—where every scoop brings a smile to my face!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in St Augustine Historic District.