The Absolute Best New York Style Pizza in Jacksonville [Updated 2025]

With a passion for pizza that rivals my love for adventure, I dove into Jacksonville’s vibrant food scene, sampling slices from twelve of the city's top pizzerias. Trust me, I didn’t just grab a quick bite; I savored every cheesy, saucy morsel, comparing crusts, flavors, and that all-important foldability.

As someone who’s spent years perfecting my palate and tracking down the best eats, I’m here to guide you through this delicious journey. Whether you’re a lifelong New Yorker missing that perfect slice or a curious foodie ready to explore, you’ll find the ultimate pizza spots that bring a taste of the Big Apple right to the River City. Let’s dig in!

Carmines Pie House

Highlights
Amazing food and prices
Outstanding service
Great atmosphere
Complimentary beers for veterans
Menu encourages indecision

Carmines Pie House met my high expectations as a haven for New York style pizza enthusiasts right here in Jacksonville. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere that perfectly balances casual dining with a hint of sophistication.

Now let’s talk about the pizza! With a menu that almost encourages indecision, choosing one slice from their diverse offerings was a delightful challenge. Each pie is a masterpiece, showcasing a thin, crispy crust paired with rich, flavorful toppings that transport you straight to the streets of New York City. And speaking of great choices, their amazing food and prices make indulging guilt-free.

To top it all off, I appreciated their outstanding service which was warm and attentive, making my visit even more enjoyable. Interestingly, they also offer complimentary beers for veterans, showcasing their commitment to the community.

In summary, if you're searching for the best New York style pizza in Jacksonville, look no further than Carmines. It's a culinary gem that combines flavorful pizza with a vibrant atmosphere, leaving your taste buds dancing and your heart full!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Biggies Pizza 5 Points Riverside

Highlights
Massive single slices
Delicious chicken ranch slice
Great customer service
Top pizza spot in Jacksonville
Quality ingredients used

Biggies Pizza 5 Points Riverside Review

When it comes to New York style pizza in Jacksonville, Biggies Pizza 5 Points Riverside undoubtedly steals the show! As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the alluring aroma of freshly baked dough. The first thing that caught my eye was the massive single slices, a hallmark of true New York style pizza – perfect for a satisfying meal or a late-night snack.

I couldn’t resist trying their famous chicken ranch slice, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The blend of flavors danced delightfully on my palate, showcasing their commitment to using quality ingredients. Each bite was a testament to their meticulous craft and love for pizza-making.

The atmosphere was laid-back, infused with a sense of community, and I must commend their great customer service. The staff was friendly and eager to recommend their favorites, which made my experience even more enjoyable.

Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or just seeking a casual dining experience, Biggies Pizza is a top pizza spot that should not be missed. If you're craving a slice that echoes the streets of New York, this is your place! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Vito's Pizza

Highlights
Crispy crust on bottom
High quality cheese
Great atmosphere and service
Generous pepperoni portion
Delicious garlic knots

At Vito's Pizza, I discovered a slice of New York delicacy right in Jacksonville. Upon entering, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that instantly set the stage for a delightful meal. The crispy crust on the bottom was a true highlight; it struck the perfect balance between crunch and chewiness, making each bite an absolute pleasure.

The cheese? Oh, let me tell you—it was of the highest quality, stretching elegantly as I lifted a slice. And speaking of slices, the generous portion of pepperoni made for a satisfying experience, each piece bursting with flavor.

To start, I couldn't resist indulging in their delicious garlic knots, which were a perfect prelude to the main event. They were warm, fluffy, and oozing with garlicky goodness—definitely worth the visit alone!

The service was commendable; friendly staff ensured that every need was met with a smile. Overall, Vito's Pizza hit all the right notes, making it a standout for anyone on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in Jacksonville. I can't wait to return for another slice!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Pizza Bella

Highlights
Delicious New York flavors
Friendly service by Ms. Karen
Secret menu options available
Quick and easy pickup
Regulars after first visit

Pizza Bella is truly a gem in the realm of new york style pizza here in Jacksonville. As soon as I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty tomato sauce enveloped me, pulling me into a slice of the Big Apple right here in the South. Ms. Karen, with her friendly smile, welcomed me warmly and shared that the secret menu options are a must-try for adventurous pizza lovers.

I opted for the classic cheese slice, and let me tell you, it didn’t disappoint. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy exterior and chewy interior—the kind that makes you want to fold your slice just like the natives do. What surprised me most was how quickly my order was ready—ideal for anyone needing a quick and easy pickup.

After just one visit, I felt like a regular! That’s the charm of Pizza Bella—it draws you in with its delicious New York flavors and keeps you coming back for more. If you find yourself in Jacksonville and craving that authentic slice, don’t hesitate to stop by Pizza Bella. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

V Pizza + Sidecar - San Marco

Nestled in the charming San Marco district, V Pizza + Sidecar serves up a slice of authentic New York style pizza that’s hard to resist. The crust strikes the perfect balance—crispy on the outside, yet delightfully chewy within. I indulged in the classic Margherita, where the fresh mozzarella and vibrant basil danced atop a rich tomato sauce; a true homage to the Big Apple. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff made my visit enjoyable, but it was the flavorful pizza that left a lasting impression. If you’re in search of a slice that transports you to NYC, this spot is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Tony D's New York Pizza & Restaurant

At Tony D's, the moment I walked in, the cozy atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm slice of pizza. The thin, crispy crust had that perfect balance—golden and slightly charred. The sauce was rich and zesty, a delightful marriage with fresh mozzarella and a sprinkle of basil. Each bite was a nostalgic trip to the streets of NYC. The generous toppings were a feast for both the eyes and palate. If you’re craving an authentic New York slice in Jacksonville, Tony D’s is a slice of heaven you won't want to miss! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

Rojas Pizza

At Rojas Pizza, I discovered a delightful slice of New York right here in Jacksonville. The crust was perfectly crisp, with a delightful chew that transported me straight to the bustling streets of Manhattan. The sauce was a vibrant blend of tomato goodness, and the cheese—oh, the cheese!—was generously layered and oozed deliciousness with every bite. Their pepperoni offered a satisfying spice, enhancing the overall flavor. The atmosphere felt genuine, with friendly staff and a cozy vibe. If you’re in search of authentic New York-style pizza that’s sure to impress, look no further than Rojas Pizza—a slice of pure joy!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.

Pizza Point

Upon entering Pizza Point, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough, perfectly set for a classic New York slice. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, and let me tell you—it was a revelation! The crust was wonderfully thin and crisp, while the pepperoni added a nice kick. Each bite offered a perfect balance of savory sauce and melted cheese, reminding me of bustling NYC pizzerias. Plus, the casual yet vibrant ambiance enhanced my experience. If you're craving an authentic slice, Pizza Point is definitely worth a visit—it's a slice of heaven in Jacksonville!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Jacksonville.

Vino's Pizza & Grill

Stepping into Vino's Pizza & Grill felt like entering a little slice of New York right in Jacksonville. Their New York style pizza boasts a thin, crispy crust that’s perfectly foldable, and the toppings are fresh and generously portioned. I savored the classic pepperoni, which was delightfully crispy, complementing the gooey cheese beneath. The ambiance has a cozy charm that welcomes you to linger a little longer. If you’re on the hunt for a slice that captures the heart and soul of NYC, Vino's is a must-visit. It’s a bold adventure in every bite! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best steak in Jacksonville.

Mega's Pizza

Stepping into Mega's Pizza feels like entering a slice of New York right here in Jacksonville. The ambiance is buzzing, but the real star is the pizza. I indulged in their classic pepperoni, and let me tell you, the crust was that perfect blend of crispy and chewy, with just the right amount of char. The sauce? Bold and tangy, with a generous layer of gooey cheese that stretched delightfully with each bite. The generous toppings balance effortlessly atop a perfectly crafted crust. If you’re seeking pizza that dances between authenticity and deliciousness, Mega's is a must-visit! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

Biggie’s Pizza Beach Blvd And Hodges

At Biggie's Pizza Beach Blvd And Hodges, each slice is a delightful homage to the classic New York style. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, making it ideal for folding, just as the pizza gods intended. Topped with a rich, zesty tomato sauce and a blanket of ooey-gooey mozzarella, it transports you straight to the streets of Manhattan with every bite. The generous toppings elevate the flavor profile without overwhelming the palette. The casual vibe and friendly staff make it a great spot for a casual dine-in or a quick slice on the go. Whether you're a local or just passing through, don’t miss this gem!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Jacksonville.

Moon River Pizza

From the moment I stepped into Moon River Pizza, the atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy New York diner. Their pizza? An irresistible blend of crispy crust, zesty tomato sauce, and a generous layer of gooey mozzarella. I savored each bite of the classic pepperoni, where the spicy slices curled up with a delightful crisp. The friendly staff made the experience even better, as if I were chatting with old friends. If you're on a quest for authentic New York-style pizza in Jacksonville, look no further than Moon River—it's a slice of the Big Apple right here in the Sunshine State!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Ponte Vedra Beach.