St Augustine's Best Margaritas [Updated 2025]

With each sip, I’ve unraveled the secrets of St. Augustine’s vibrant margarita scene, diving headfirst into the flavors that make this city a haven for cocktail lovers. Trust me, I’ve sipped my way through twelve of the top spots, each one serving up a unique blend that tells its own story.

Whether you’re looking for a classic lime burst or a daring twist with exotic fruits, I've tasted it all and am here to guide you through this delightful journey. After all, when it comes to finding the perfect margarita, who better to lead the way than someone who’s spent years savoring the best this beautiful city has to offer? Let’s raise a glass to the unforgettable flavors waiting for you!

Casa Maya

Highlights
Exceptional customer service
Great food and atmosphere
Delicious bar drinks
Live music entertainment
Generous portion sizes

When it comes to finding the best margaritas in St Augustine, Casa Maya is a true gem! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with exceptional customer service that set the tone for an unforgettable evening. The warm and inviting atmosphere felt like a small slice of Mexico right in the heart of St Augustine.

Now, let’s talk margaritas—oh, the margaritas! Each sip revealed a perfect balance of fresh ingredients, with the tangy zest of lime harmonizing beautifully with the smooth tequila. Their signature margarita, served on the rocks, was an explosion of flavor—definitely one for the books. I also appreciated the generous portion sizes, allowing me to savor every drop while enjoying lively conversations.

To top it off, Casa Maya offers live music entertainment in the background, perfectly complementing the overall vibe. Paired with their mouthwatering dishes, this place is not just about the margaritas; it’s a full-on experience! If you're on the hunt for a fantastic margarita, look no further. Casa Maya is a must-visit for anyone who loves a refreshing cocktail elevated by delightful surroundings. Cheers to that!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar, St. Augustine

Highlights
Excellent Tacos
Over-the-Top Service
Inviting Decor
Friendly and Helpful Staff
Must-Try Quesabirria Tacos

La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar is a vibrant gem in St. Augustine that truly knows how to serve up a satisfying margarita. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by an inviting atmosphere adorned with colorful decor that sets the perfect backdrop for a delightful evening.

I indulged in their famed margaritas and was instantly swept away by the balance of flavors—not too sweet, not too tart, just the way I like it. The extra kick of fresh lime made it an exhilarating sip, and paired wonderfully with their must-try quesabirria tacos. Oh, and let’s not forget the over-the-top service; the staff was not just friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable about their tequila offerings, which made my experience that much richer.

Every detail was on point, from the dynamic drink menu to their tasty tacos, enhancing the overall enjoyment of my visit. La Catrina is not just a place to grab a drink; it’s a vibrant celebration of flavors and fun. If you’re hunting for the best margaritas in St. Augustine, this place should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Taco's Queen

Highlights
Special fish tacos
Must-visit for locals
Nice ambiance outside
Good takeout options
Inconsistent service quality

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Taco's Queen is a must-visit gem for those seeking a margarita that dances on your palate. The ambiance outside invites you to relax and soak in the warm Floridian sun while enjoying a delicious drink. I was eager to try their signature margarita, which was touted as a crowd favorite. And let me tell you, this margarita exceeded my expectations!

The balance of sweet and tangy was impeccable, with just the right amount of salt on the rim. It was refreshing and vibrant, a true testament to their mixology skills.

Additionally, their special fish tacos complemented the drink perfectly, creating a delicious synergy of flavors that left me wanting more. While I did notice some inconsistent service quality during my visit, the vibrant atmosphere and tasty offerings more than made up for it.

For anyone looking for a solid margarita experience, Taco's Queen is worthy of your time. Just make sure to take a moment to savor each sip—these margaritas might just make you want to raise a glass and celebrate life! 🍹✨

You might also want to check out the best seafood in Jacksonville.

Taberna del Caballo

Highlights
Outdoor seating available
Dog friendly atmosphere
Tremendous team service
Amazing datil hot sauce
Sneaky good food options

Taberna del Caballo is a delightful gem where the margaritas shine as bright as the sun. As I settled into the charming outdoor seating, I was welcomed by a friendly team that enhanced my experience right from the start. Their warm hospitality made me feel right at home, which is always a plus when enjoying a drink.

I ordered their signature margarita, and let me tell you, it was a true fiesta in a glass! The balance of flavors struck a perfect chord, delivering a refreshing and zesty experience that danced on my taste buds. The secret star of the show? A dash of their amazing datil hot sauce, which added an unexpected kick that elevated the classic margarita.

As I sipped and savored, I also noticed the dog-friendly vibe, making it an ideal stop for those who enjoy having their furry companions with them. And let's not forget that their menu features sneaky good food options that pair splendidly with the star drink. With a cozy ambiance and an attentive staff, Taberna del Caballo truly captures the essence of St Augustine’s vibrant spirit. I'll definitely be back for another round!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Taco Libre #3

Highlights
No wait time for seating
Delicious birria tacos
$6 margaritas on trivia night
Attentive and kind service
Indoor and outdoor seating

Taco Libre #3 quickly captured my attention with its inviting atmosphere and prompt seating—no waiting in a line for me! As I settled in, I couldn’t resist the allure of their $6 margaritas during trivia night. What a delightful surprise! Each sip was a harmonious blend of tart lime and smooth tequila, perfectly refreshing for warm St Augustine nights.

To complement my drink, I indulged in their delicious birria tacos, which paired flawlessly with the margarita's citrusy notes. It was a match made in culinary heaven! The service was notably attentive and kind, making the evening even more enjoyable.

With the option of both indoor and outdoor seating, Taco Libre #3 provides the perfect backdrop for friendly gatherings or a cozy dinner for two. Honestly, their margaritas might just be among the best in St Augustine. If you find yourself wandering these charming streets, do yourself a favor and make this stop—your taste buds will thank you! Cheers to delicious drinks and delightful company!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.

Mayita

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Mayita is a vibrant gem that absolutely dazzles with its margaritas. The classic lime margarita features a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness, served with a delightful salted rim that enhances every sip. I couldn't resist trying their spicy jalapeño margarita, which added an exhilarating twist that danced on my palate. The atmosphere is lively, and the friendly staff elevate the experience even further. Each drink is a testament to their craftsmanship, making Mayita a top contender in my quest for the best margarita in town. Cheers to good vibes and fantastic flavors!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Jacksonville.

Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila

At Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, I found a margarita that truly dazzled my taste buds. Their signature spicy margarita packs a delightful punch, blending fresh lime juice with a hint of jalapeño, all perfectly balanced by a smooth, premium tequila. The vibrant atmosphere and colorful décor add to the experience, making each sip feel like a celebration. The friendly staff enhances the vibe, ensuring your drink is just the way you like it. If you're searching for a refreshing twist on the classic, this spot is a must-visit on your St Augustine margarita journey!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in St Augustine.

Cantina Louie (St. Augustine, FL)

At Cantina Louie, I was greeted by a vibrant atmosphere that sets the perfect backdrop for a delightful drink. Their signature margarita delivers a zingy punch of fresh lime, perfectly balanced with a smooth tequila base. The addition of house-made simple syrup adds a touch of sweetness that caresses the palate. Served in a generously rimmed glass with a dusting of tangy tajín, every sip is a fiesta. The staff was incredibly friendly, enhancing the overall experience. If you're hunting for an invigorating margarita to sip while soaking in the St. Augustine vibe, Cantina Louie is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Jacksonville.

Jimmy Hula's Saint Augustine

Jimmy Hula's Saint Augustine is a vibrant oasis that delivers a refreshingly fun twist on the classic margarita. I was instantly captivated by their Tropical Margarita, a delightful blend of lime, fresh pineapple, and a hint of coconut. Each sip transported me directly to a sun-soaked beach.

The atmosphere buzzed with energy, making it the perfect spot to unwind. I also appreciated their choice of handcrafted spirits, elevating the experience. Overall, if you're seeking a margarita that evokes a tropical escape, look no further than Jimmy Hula's. It’s definitely a contender in St Augustine's margarita scene!

You might also want to check out the best steak in Jacksonville.

Playa Chacmool Inc

At Playa Chacmool Inc, I was greeted by the vibrant colors and tantalizing aromas that set the stage for an unforgettable margarita experience. Their signature margarita boasts a perfect balance of tart lime and smooth tequila, with a delightful twist from freshly muddled jalapeños. Each sip dances on the palate, igniting a fiesta in my mouth! The atmosphere is as lively as the drinks, making it an ideal spot to unwind. Don't miss their salt-rimmed glasses that elevate the experience to new heights. If you’re seeking a margarita that truly captivates, Playa Chacmool Inc is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in St Augustine.

Anejo Cocina Parkway - St Augustine

Anejo Cocina Parkway in St. Augustine is a must-visit for margarita lovers! The vibrant atmosphere sets the stage for an unforgettable experience. I indulged in their signature margarita, crafted with fresh lime juice and organic agave nectar. Each sip danced on my palate, perfectly balancing tart and sweet. The addition of a homemade chili salt rim elevated the experience to new heights. Service was warm and attentive, making me feel right at home. If you’re in the mood for a delightful twist on a classic, Anejo should definitely be on your radar for the best margaritas in town! 🍹✨

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Jacksonville.

Prohibition Kitchen

At Prohibition Kitchen, the margarita offerings are a delightful escape into flavor. I savored the Spicy Margarita, which perfectly balanced the heat of fresh jalapeño with the zing of lime, all elevated by a hint of smoky mezcal. The atmosphere buzzes with a fun, vintage vibe, complementing the handcrafted cocktails. Each sip transported me to a sunny fiesta! The friendly staff adds to the charm, offering recommendations with genuine enthusiasm. If you're in the market for a refreshing twist on this classic drink, Prohibition Kitchen should be at the top of your list for the best margaritas in St Augustine!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Ponte Vedra Beach.