St Augustine's Best Italian Restaurants [Updated 2025]

As I’ve savored every slice of pizza and twirled countless forks of pasta in this charming city, I’ve honed my taste buds to spot the real gems among the trattorias and pizzerias. After dining at twelve top-notch spots, I can confidently say that St. Augustine is a hidden treasure chest of authentic Italian flavors that will make your mouth water.

You can trust my picks because I’ve immersed myself in the local food scene, exploring everything from cozy family-run eateries to upscale dining experiences. Each restaurant has its own unique story and culinary flair, and I can’t wait to share the delicious details with you!

Saint Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Elegant waterfront dining
Exceptional service and ambiance
Must-try bread service
Beautiful outdoor courtyard
Delicious 100-layer lasagna

Saint Italian Restaurant in St Augustine is a true gem, seamlessly marrying elegance with a warm, inviting atmosphere. As I stepped through the charming door, the beautiful waterfront views immediately caught my eye. The outdoor courtyard provided a picturesque backdrop, perfect for a leisurely meal.

One of the highlights of my visit was the exceptional bread service. It was not just bread; it was an inviting, fluffy treat that set the stage for what was to come. For my main course, I dove into the 100-layer lasagna, a culinary masterpiece that artfully balanced flavors and textures. Each layer told a story, bringing together rich meat sauce and decadent cheese in a way that left my taste buds singing.

What truly made my experience unforgettable was the impeccable service. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, making me feel right at home. Their recommendations were spot-on and added to my overall enjoyment. In a city brimming with dining options, Saint Italian Restaurant stands out not just for its food but also for its breathtaking atmosphere and exceptional service. If you're seeking authentic Italian cuisine, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Jacksonville.

Amici Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Top-notch service and care
Amazing penne with chicken
Garlic dipping sauce delight
Well-trained kitchen staff
Best Italian food experience

Ah, where to begin with Amici Italian Restaurant? From the moment I walked in, the charming ambiance wrapped around me like a warm Italian embrace. The top-notch service made every moment delightful; the staff was attentive and genuinely passionate about sharing their love for Italian cuisine.

Now, let’s talk about the amazing penne with chicken. This dish showcased a perfect al dente pasta enveloped in a rich, flavorful sauce that danced on my palate. It’s a testament to the well-trained kitchen staff who clearly pour their heart into every plate.

And if you think that’s where the pleasure ends, think again! The garlic dipping sauce delight provided alongside the fresh bread had me hooked from the first bite. I can’t recall ever experiencing such a glorious union of flavors that kept me reaching for more.

For anyone seeking the best Italian food experience in St Augustine, Amici is an absolute must-visit. The combination of convivial atmosphere, exceptional dishes, and attentive service leaves you feeling like part of the family. I left with a heart full of joy and a satisfied belly, ready to return for another round of culinary delight!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Jacksonville.

Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen

Highlights
Best Chicken Marsala
Delicious thin-crust pizza
Friendly staff and nice atmosphere
Must-try tiramisu
Call ahead to avoid wait

At Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen, I found myself transported to Italy with every bite! As I stepped inside, the warm atmosphere enveloped me, inviting me to relax and enjoy. The friendly staff greeted me like an old friend, which immediately set the tone for a delightful evening.

Now let’s talk food—oh, the Chicken Marsala! If there’s one dish that sings with perfection, it’s this one. Tender chicken bathed in a rich, savory sauce paired beautifully with earthy mushrooms. Don’t even get me started on their thin-crust pizza; it’s a heavenly combination of crispy edges and bubbly cheese that I couldn’t resist devouring.

To cap off my meal, I indulged in the must-try tiramisu. Its creamy texture and just the right balance of coffee and sweetness made my heart skip a beat!

If you're planning a visit, be sure to call ahead—this gem can get busy! Overall, Simone's Wood Fired Craft Kitchen offers a delicious slice of Italia right here in St Augustine, making it one of the best Italian establishments in town. You won't regret it! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Jacksonville.

Nonnas Trattoria

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Nonna's Trattoria feels like a warm hug from nonna herself! The moment I stepped inside, the aroma of garlic and herbs whisked me away to Italy. I indulged in their homemade lasagna, layered with rich béchamel and zesty marinara—simply divine! The cozy ambiance, complete with charming décor, made my meal unforgettable. Don't miss their luscious Tiramisu, which offers a delightful end to the feast. If you're in search of authentic Italian flair and heartfelt service, Nonna's is surely a top contender in St. Augustine’s culinary scene!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in St Augustine.

Pizzalley's Chianti Room

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Pizzalley's Chianti Room took my taste buds on a delightful escapade. The warm ambiance exudes an inviting charm—perfect for a romantic dinner or a lively gathering. I savored their homemade pasta, which was a testament to authentic Italian craftsmanship. The marinara sauce, rich and vibrant, danced with flavors that transported me straight to Italy. Don’t skip dessert; their tiramisu is truly divine! The attentive service and cozy atmosphere make it a must-visit spot. If you’re on the hunt for Italian bliss, Pizzalley’s is an experience you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Jacksonville.

Poppys Italiano

Upon stepping into Poppy's Italiano, I was immediately enveloped by a warm, inviting atmosphere that felt like a taste of Italy. The menu boasts a delightful array of classic dishes, and I couldn't resist their homemade lasagna, which was a heavenly blend of rich ricotta and savory meat sauce. The garlic bread was crispy perfection, complementing the meal beautifully. Each bite felt like a culinary embrace! The staff was attentive, adding to the overall charm. If you're craving authentic flavors and a cozy vibe, Poppy's is a must-visit gem in St. Augustine. Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurants in Jacksonville.

Casa Benedetto's

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Casa Benedetto’s is a delightful escape into authentic Italian cuisine. As soon as you step inside, the aromas of garlic and herbs embrace you. The handmade pasta dances on your palate, especially their rich fettuccine Alfredo—a creamy dream that I simply couldn't resist! The warm, inviting atmosphere is perfect for both leisurely dinners and lively gatherings. Don’t skip dessert—the tiramisù is an indulgent finale that will leave you enchanted. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Casa Benedetto’s is a must-visit gem that captures the essence of Italy with every bite!

You might also want to check out the best cuban restaurant in St Augustine.

Terra & Acqua

During my delightful evening at Terra & Acqua, I discovered a charming blend of rustic Italian cuisine and warm hospitality. From the moment I stepped inside, the inviting ambiance set the stage for a culinary adventure. I savored their creamy truffle fettuccine, which danced on my palate with rich flavors. The wood-fired pizzas were nothing short of perfection, boasting a crispy crust topped with fresh ingredients. To top it off, the service was impeccable, making me feel like part of the family. If you're seeking a memorable Italian dining experience in St Augustine, Terra & Acqua is a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Sogno Restaurant

Tucked away in the charming streets of St. Augustine, Sogno Restaurant is a delightful culinary gem that transports you straight to Italy. From the moment I entered, the cozy ambiance and friendly staff welcomed me with open arms. I savored their homemade gnocchi, which was light as a cloud and bathed in a rich, velvety sauce that danced on my palate. The wood-fired pizzas are a must-try, boasting a perfectly charred crust and fresh toppings that sing with flavor. If you’re in search of authentic Italian cuisine with a dash of local charm, Sogno is your dream come true!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Jacksonville Beach.

Vilano Grill 180

At Vilano Grill 180, I was greeted by a delightful ambiance that set the stage for an unforgettable meal. The homemade pasta was a true standout, topped with a rich marinara that danced on my palate. The seafood linguine was a symphony of flavors, with fresh shrimp and clams making a grand entrance. I couldn’t resist indulging in their tiramisu—a heavenly finale that left me wanting more. Service was prompt and attentive, allowing me to savor each bite without a care in the world. If you're in the mood for genuine Italian fare with a twist, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Fernandina Beach.

Piesanos St Augustine

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Piesanos St Augustine is a delightful gem that serves up delicious pizza and authentic Italian dishes. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a warm ambiance and friendly staff. The rich marinara sauce on my pasta left me craving more, while the wood-fired pizza, with its perfectly charred crust, was simply divine. Each bite was a harmonious blend of fresh ingredients and love. For a casual yet satisfying Italian experience, Piesanos truly hits the mark! Don't miss their desserts—they're the perfect sweet ending to your meal!

You might also want to check out the best seafood in St Augustine.

Violas

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, Violas is a delightful find for any italian cuisine enthusiast. The moment I stepped inside, the charming ambiance wrapped around me like a warm hug. Their house-made pasta is a revelation—each bite bursting with flavor and authenticity. I savored the creamy fettuccine Alfredo, which was a decadent treat that left me craving more. Not to mention the attentive staff, who made me feel like part of the family. If you're searching for Italian comfort food in a cozy setting, Violas is a must-visit destination. Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Jacksonville.